In mathematics, a negative number represents an opposite. In the real number system, a negative number is a number that is less than zero. Negative numbers are often used to represent the magnitude of a loss or deficiency. A debt that is owed may be thought of as a negative asset, a decrease in some quantity may be thought of as a negative increase. If a quantity, such as the charge on an electron, may have either of two opposite senses, then one may choose to distinguish between those senses—perhaps arbitrarily—as positive and negative. Negative numbers are used to describe values on a scale that goes below zero, such as the Celsius and Fahrenheit scales for temperature. The laws of arithmetic for negative numbers ensure that the common-sense idea of an opposite is reflected in arithmetic. For example, −(−3) = 3 because the opposite of an opposite is the original value.
Negative numbers are usually written with a minus sign in front. For example, −3 represents a negative quantity with a magnitude of three, and is pronounced "minus three" or "negative three". To help tell the difference between a subtraction operation and a negative number, occasionally the negative sign is placed slightly higher than the minus sign (as a superscript). Conversely, a number that is greater than zero is called positive; zero is usually (but not always) thought of as neither positive nor negative. The positivity of a number may be emphasized by placing a plus sign before it, e.g. +3. In general, the negativity or positivity of a number is referred to as its sign.
Every real number other than zero is either positive or negative. The non-negative whole numbers are referred to as natural numbers (i.e., 0, 1, 2, 3...), while the positive and negative whole numbers (together with zero) are referred to as integers. (Some definitions of the natural numbers exclude zero.)
In bookkeeping, amounts owed are often represented by red numbers, or a number in parentheses, as an alternative notation to represent negative numbers.
Negative numbers appeared for the first time in history in the Nine Chapters on the Mathematical Art, which in its present form dates from the period of the Chinese Han Dynasty (202 BC – AD 220), but may well contain much older material. Liu Hui (c. 3rd century) established rules for adding and subtracting negative numbers. By the 7th century, Indian mathematicians such as Brahmagupta were describing the use of negative numbers. Islamic mathematicians further developed the rules of subtracting and multiplying negative numbers and solved problems with negative coefficients. Prior to the concept of negative numbers, mathematicians such as Diophantus considered negative solutions to problems "false" and equations requiring negative solutions were described as absurd. Western mathematicians like Leibniz (1646–1716) held that negative numbers were invalid, but still used them in calculations.
As the result of subtraction
Negative numbers can be thought of as resulting from the subtraction of a larger number from a smaller. For example, negative three is the result of subtracting three from zero:
- 0 − 3 = −3.
In general, the subtraction of a larger number from a smaller yields a negative result, with the magnitude of the result being the difference between the two numbers. For example,
- 5 − 8 = −3
since 8 − 5 = 3.
The number line
The relationship between negative numbers, positive numbers, and zero is often expressed in the form of a number line:
Numbers appearing farther to the right on this line are greater, while numbers appearing farther to the left are less. Thus zero appears in the middle, with the positive numbers to the right and the negative numbers to the left.
Note that a negative number with greater magnitude is considered less. For example, even though (positive) 8 is greater than (positive) 5, written
- 8 > 5
negative 8 is considered to be less than negative 5:
- −8 < −5.
(Because, for example, if you have £−8, a debt of £8, you would have less after adding, say £10, to it than if you have £−5.) It follows that any negative number is less than any positive number, so
- −8 < 5 and −5 < 8.
In the context of negative numbers, a number that is greater than zero is referred to as positive. Thus every real number other than zero is either positive or negative, while zero itself is not considered to have a sign. Positive numbers are sometimes written with a plus sign in front, e.g. +3 denotes a positive three.
Because zero is neither positive nor negative, the term nonnegative is sometimes used to refer to a number that is either positive or zero, while nonpositive is used to refer to a number that is either negative or zero. Zero is a neutral number.
Everyday uses of negative numbers
- Goal difference in association football and hockey; points difference in rugby football; net run rate in cricket; golf scores relative to par.
- Plus-minus differential in ice hockey: the difference in total goals scored for the team (+) and against the team (−) when a particular player is on the ice is the player's +/− rating. Players can have a negative (+/−) rating.
- Run differential in baseball: the run differential is negative if the team allows more runs than they scored.
- Clubs may be deducted points for breaches of the laws, and thus have a negative points total until they have earned at least that many points that season.
- Lap (or sector) times in Formula 1 may be given as the difference compared to a previous lap (or sector) (such as the previous record, or the lap just completed by a driver in front), and will be positive if slower and negative if faster.
- In some athletics events, such as sprint races, the hurdles, the triple jump and the long jump, the wind assistance is measured and recorded, and is positive for a tailwind and negative for a headwind.
- Temperatures which are colder than 0 °C or 0 °F.
- Latitudes south of the equator and longitudes west of the prime meridian.
- Topographical features of the earth's surface are given a height above sea level, which can be negative (e.g. the surface elevation of the Dead Sea or Death Valley, or the elevation of the Thames Tideway Tunnel).
- Electrical circuits. When a battery is connected in reverse polarity, the voltage applied is said to be the opposite of its rated voltage. For example, a 6-volt battery connected in reverse applies a voltage of −6 volts.
- Ions have a positive or negative electrical charge.
- Impedance of an AM broadcast tower used in multi-tower directional antenna arrays, which can be positive or negative.
- Financial statements can include negative balances, indicated either by a minus sign or by enclosing the balance in parentheses. Examples include bank account overdrafts and business losses (negative earnings).
- Refunds to a credit card or debit card are a negative charge to the card.
- The annual percentage growth in a country's GDP might be negative, which is one indicator of being in a recession.
- Occasionally, a rate of inflation may be negative (deflation), indicating a fall in average prices.
- The daily change in a share price or stock market index, such as the FTSE 100 or the Dow Jones.
- A negative number in financing is synonymous with "debt" and "deficit" which are also known as "being in the red".
- Interest rates can be negative, when the lender is charged to deposit their money.
- The numbering of storeys in a building below the ground floor.
- When playing an audio file on a portable media player, such as an iPod, the screen display may show the time remaining as a negative number, which increases up to zero at the same rate as the time already played increases from zero.
- Television game shows:
- Participants on QI often finish with a negative points score.
- Teams on University Challenge have a negative score if their first answers are incorrect and interrupt the question.
- Jeopardy! has a negative money score – contestants play for an amount of money and any incorrect answer that costs them more than what they have now can result in a negative score.
- In The Price Is Right's pricing game Buy or Sell, if an amount of money is lost that is more than the amount currently in the bank, it incurs a negative score.
- The change in support for a political party between elections, known as swing.
- A politician's approval rating.
- In video games, a negative number indicates loss of life, damage, a score penalty, or consumption of a resource, depending on the genre of the simulation.
- Employees with flexible working hours may have a negative balance on their timesheet if they have worked fewer total hours than contracted to that point. Employees may be able to take more than their annual holiday allowance in a year, and carry forward a negative balance to the next year.
- Transposing notes on an electronic keyboard are shown on the display with positive numbers for increases and negative numbers for decreases, e.g. "−1" for one semitone down.
Arithmetic involving negative numbers
The minus sign "−" signifies the operator for both the binary (two-operand) operation of subtraction (as in y − z) and the unary (one-operand) operation of negation (as in −x, or twice in −(−x)). A special case of unary negation occurs when it operates on a positive number, in which case the result is a negative number (as in −5).
The ambiguity of the "−" symbol does not generally lead to ambiguity in arithmetical expressions, because the order of operations makes only one interpretation or the other possible for each "−". However, it can lead to confusion and be difficult for a person to understand an expression when operator symbols appear adjacent to one another. A solution can be to parenthesize the unary "−" along with its operand.
For example, the expression 7 + −5 may be clearer if written 7 + (−5) (even though they mean exactly the same thing formally). The subtraction expression 7 – 5 is a different expression that doesn't represent the same operations, but it evaluates to the same result.
- −2 + −5 gives −7.
Addition of two negative numbers is very similar to addition of two positive numbers. For example,
- (−3) + (−5) = −8.
The idea is that two debts can be combined into a single debt of greater magnitude.
When adding together a mixture of positive and negative numbers, one can think of the negative numbers as positive quantities being subtracted. For example:
- 8 + (−3) = 8 − 3 = 5 and (−2) + 7 = 7 − 2 = 5.
In the first example, a credit of 8 is combined with a debt of 3, which yields a total credit of 5. If the negative number has greater magnitude, then the result is negative:
- (−8) + 3 = 3 − 8 = −5 and 2 + (−7) = 2 − 7 = −5.
Here the credit is less than the debt, so the net result is a debt.
As discussed above, it is possible for the subtraction of two non-negative numbers to yield a negative answer:
- 5 − 8 = −3
In general, subtraction of a positive number yields the same result as the addition of a negative number of equal magnitude. Thus
- 5 − 8 = 5 + (−8) = −3
- (−3) − 5 = (−3) + (−5) = −8
On the other hand, subtracting a negative number yields the same result as the addition a positive number of equal magnitude. (The idea is that losing a debt is the same thing as gaining a credit.) Thus
- 3 − (−5) = 3 + 5 = 8
- (−5) − (−8) = (−5) + 8 = 3.
When multiplying numbers, the magnitude of the product is always just the product of the two magnitudes. The sign of the product is determined by the following rules:
- The product of one positive number and one negative number is negative.
- The product of two negative numbers is positive.
- (−2) × 3 = −6
- (−2) × (−3) = 6.
The reason behind the first example is simple: adding three −2's together yields −6:
- (−2) × 3 = (−2) + (−2) + (−2) = −6.
The reasoning behind the second example is more complicated. The idea again is that losing a debt is the same thing as gaining a credit. In this case, losing two debts of three each is the same as gaining a credit of six:
- (−2 debts ) × (−3 each) = +6 credit.
The convention that a product of two negative numbers is positive is also necessary for multiplication to follow the distributive law. In this case, we know that
- (−2) × (−3) + 2 × (−3) = (−2 + 2) × (−3) = 0 × (−3) = 0.
Since 2 × (−3) = −6, the product (−2) × (−3) must equal 6.
These rules lead to another (equivalent) rule—the sign of any product a × b depends on the sign of a as follows:
- if a is positive, then the sign of a × b is the same as the sign of b, and
- if a is negative, then the sign of a × b is the opposite of the sign of b.
The justification for why the product of two negative numbers is a positive number can be observed in the analysis of complex numbers.
The sign rules for division are the same as for multiplication. For example,
- 8 ÷ (−2) = −4,
- (−8) ÷ 2 = −4,
- (−8) ÷ (−2) = 4.
If dividend and divisor have the same sign, the result is positive, if they have different signs the result is negative.
The negative version of a positive number is referred to as its negation. For example, −3 is the negation of the positive number 3. The sum of a number and its negation is equal to zero:
- 3 + (−3) = 0.
That is, the negation of a positive number is the additive inverse of the number.
- x + (−x) = 0.
This identity holds for any positive number x. It can be made to hold for all real numbers by extending the definition of negation to include zero and negative numbers. Specifically:
- The negation of 0 is 0, and
- The negation of a negative number is the corresponding positive number.
For example, the negation of −3 is +3. In general,
- −(−x) = x.
The absolute value of a number is the non-negative number with the same magnitude. For example, the absolute value of −3 and the absolute value of 3 are both equal to 3, and the absolute value of 0 is 0.
Formal construction of negative integers
In a similar manner to rational numbers, we can extend the natural numbers N to the integers Z by defining integers as an ordered pair of natural numbers (a, b). We can extend addition and multiplication to these pairs with the following rules:
- (a, b) + (c, d) = (a + c, b + d)
- (a, b) × (c, d) = (a × c + b × d, a × d + b × c)
We define an equivalence relation ~ upon these pairs with the following rule:
- (a, b) ~ (c, d) if and only if a + d = b + c.
This equivalence relation is compatible with the addition and multiplication defined above, and we may define Z to be the quotient set N²/~, i.e. we identify two pairs (a, b) and (c, d) if they are equivalent in the above sense. Note that Z, equipped with these operations of addition and multiplication, is a ring, and is in fact, the prototypical example of a ring.
We can also define a total order on Z by writing
- (a, b) ≤ (c, d) if and only if a + d ≤ b + c.
This will lead to an additive zero of the form (a, a), an additive inverse of (a, b) of the form (b, a), a multiplicative unit of the form (a + 1, a), and a definition of subtraction
- (a, b) − (c, d) = (a + d, b + c).
This construction is a special case of the Grothendieck construction.
The negative of a number is unique, as is shown by the following proof.
Let x be a number and let y be its negative. Suppose y′ is another negative of x. By an axiom of the real number system
And so, x + y′ = x + y. Using the law of cancellation for addition, it is seen that y′ = y. Thus y is equal to any other negative of x. That is, y is the unique negative of x.
For a long time, negative solutions to problems were considered "false". In Hellenistic Egypt, the Greek mathematician Diophantus in the 3rd century AD referred to an equation that was equivalent to 4x + 20 = 4 (which has a negative solution) in Arithmetica, saying that the equation was absurd. For this reason Greek geometers were able to solve geometrically all forms of the quadratic equation which give positive roots; while they could take no account of others.
Negative numbers appear for the first time in history in the Nine Chapters on the Mathematical Art (Jiu zhang suan-shu), which in its present form dates from the period of the Han Dynasty (202 BC – AD 220), but may well contain much older material. The mathematician Liu Hui (c. 3rd century) established rules for the addition and subtraction of negative numbers. The historian Jean-Claude Martzloff theorized that the importance of duality in Chinese natural philosophy made it easier for the Chinese to accept the idea of negative numbers. The Chinese were able to solve simultaneous equations involving negative numbers. The Nine Chapters used red counting rods to denote positive coefficients and black rods for negative. This system is the exact opposite of contemporary printing of positive and negative numbers in the fields of banking, accounting, and commerce, wherein red numbers denote negative values and black numbers signify positive values. Liu Hui writes:
The ancient Indian Bakhshali Manuscript carried out calculations with negative numbers, using "+" as a negative sign. The date of the manuscript is uncertain. LV Gurjar dates it no later than the 4th century, Hoernle dates it between the third and fourth centuries, Ayyangar and Pingree dates it to the 8th or 9th centuries, and George Gheverghese Joseph dates it to about AD 400 and no later than the early 7th century,
During the 7th century AD, negative numbers were used in India to represent debts. The Indian mathematician Brahmagupta, in Brahma-Sphuta-Siddhanta (written c. AD 630), discussed the use of negative numbers to produce the general form quadratic formula that remains in use today. He also found negative solutions of quadratic equations and gave rules regarding operations involving negative numbers and zero, such as "A debt cut off from nothingness becomes a credit; a credit cut off from nothingness becomes a debt." He called positive numbers "fortunes", zero "a cipher", and negative numbers "debts".
In the 9th century, Islamic mathematicians were familiar with negative numbers from the works of Indian mathematicians, but the recognition and use of negative numbers during this period remained timid. Al-Khwarizmi in his Al-jabr wa'l-muqabala (from which we get the word "algebra") did not use negative numbers or negative coefficients. But within fifty years, Abu Kamil illustrated the rules of signs for expanding the multiplication , and al-Karaji wrote in his al-Fakhrī that "negative quantities must be counted as terms". In the 10th century, Abū al-Wafā' al-Būzjānī considered debts as negative numbers in A Book on What Is Necessary from the Science of Arithmetic for Scribes and Businessmen.
the product of a negative number—al-nāqiṣ—by a positive number—al-zāʾid—is negative, and by a negative number is positive. If we subtract a negative number from a higher negative number, the remainder is their negative difference. The difference remains positive if we subtract a negative number from a lower negative number. If we subtract a negative number from a positive number, the remainder is their positive sum. If we subtract a positive number from an empty power (martaba khāliyya), the remainder is the same negative, and if we subtract a negative number from an empty power, the remainder is the same positive number.
In the 12th century in India, Bhāskara II gave negative roots for quadratic equations but rejected them because they were inappropriate in the context of the problem. He stated that a negative value is "in this case not to be taken, for it is inadequate; people do not approve of negative roots."
European mathematicians, for the most part, resisted the concept of negative numbers until the middle of the 19th century (!) In the 18th century it was common practice to ignore any negative results derived from equations, on the assumption that they were meaningless. In A.D. 1759, Francis Maseres, an English mathematician, wrote that negative numbers "darken the very whole doctrines of the equations and make dark of the things which are in their nature excessively obvious and simple". He came to the conclusion that negative numbers were nonsensical.
Fibonacci allowed negative solutions in financial problems where they could be interpreted as debits (chapter 13 of Liber Abaci, AD 1202) and later as losses (in Flos). In the 15th century, Nicolas Chuquet, a Frenchman, used negative numbers as exponents but referred to them as "absurd numbers". In his 1544 Arithmetica Integra Michael Stifel also dealt with negative numbers, also calling them numeri absurdi. In 1545, Gerolamo Cardano, in his Ars Magna, provided the first satisfactory treatment of negative numbers in Europe. He did not allow negative numbers in his consideration of cubic equations, so he had to treat, for example, x3 + ax = b separately from x3 = ax + b (with a,b > 0 in both cases). In all, Cardano was driven to the study of thirteen different types of cubic equations, each expressed purely in terms of positive numbers. (Cardano also dealt with complex numbers, but understandably liked them even less.)
- "Integers are the set of whole numbers and their opposites.", Richard W. Fisher, No-Nonsense Algebra, 2nd Edition, Math Essentials, ISBN 978-0999443330
- The convention that zero is neither positive nor negative is not universal. For example, in the French convention, zero is considered to be both positive and negative. The French words positif and négatif mean the same as English "positive or zero" and "negative or zero" respectively.
- Struik, pages 32–33. "In these matrices we find negative numbers, which appear here for the first time in history."
- Luke Hodgkin (2005). A History of Mathematics: From Mesopotamia to Modernity. Oxford University Press. p. 88. ISBN 978-0-19-152383-0.
Liu is explicit on this; at the point where the Nine Chapters give a detailed and helpful 'Sign Rule'
- Rashed, R. (30 June 1994). The Development of Arabic Mathematics: Between Arithmetic and Algebra. Springer. pp. 36–37. ISBN 9780792325659.
- Diophantus, Arithmetica.
- Kline, Morris (1972). Mathematical Thought from Ancient to Modern Times. Oxford University Press, New York. p. 252.
- Martha Smith. "History of Negative Numbers".
- "Saracens salary cap breach: Premiership champions will not contest sanctions". BBC. Retrieved 18 November 2019.
Mark McCall's side have subsequently dropped from third to bottom of the Premiership with −22 points
- "Bolton Wanderers 1−0 Milton Keynes Dons". BBC. Retrieved 30 November 2019.
But in the third minute of stoppage time, the striker turned in Luke Murphy's cross from eight yards to earn a third straight League One win for Hill's side, who started the campaign on −12 points after going into administration in May.
- "Glossary". Formula1.com. Retrieved 30 November 2019.
Delta time: A term used to describe the time difference between two different laps or two different cars. For example, there is usually a negative delta between a driver's best practice lap time and his best qualifying lap time because he uses a low fuel load and new tyres.
- "BBC Sport - Olympic Games - London 2012 - Men's Long Jump : Athletics - Results". 5 August 2012. Archived from the original on 5 August 2012. Retrieved 5 December 2018.
- "How Wind Assistance Works in Track & Field". elitefeet.com. Retrieved 18 November 2019.
Wind assistance is normally expressed in meters per second, either positive or negative. A positive measurement means that the wind is helping the runners and a negative measurement means that the runners had to work against the wind. So, for example, winds of −2.2m/s and +1.9m/s are legal, while a wind of +2.1m/s is too much assistance and considered illegal. The terms "tailwind" and "headwind" are also frequently used. A tailwind pushes the runners forward (+) while a headwind pushes the runners backwards (−)
- Forbes, Robert B. (6 January 1975). Contributions to the Geology of the Bering Sea Basin and Adjacent Regions: Selected Papers from the Symposium on the Geology and Geophysics of the Bering Sea Region, on the Occasion of the Inauguration of the C. T. Elvey Building, University of Alaska, June 26-28, 1970, and from the 2d International Symposium on Arctic Geology Held in San Francisco, February 1-4, 1971. Geological Society of America. p. 194. ISBN 9780813721514.
- Wilks, Daniel S. (6 January 2018). Statistical Methods in the Atmospheric Sciences. Academic Press. p. 17. ISBN 9780123850225.
- Carysforth, Carol; Neild, Mike (2002), Double Award, Heinemann, p. 375, ISBN 978-0-435-44746-5
- Gerver, Robert K.; Sgroi, Richard J. (2010), Financial Algebra, Student Edition, Cengage Learning, p. 201, ISBN 978-0-538-44967-0
- What Does a Negative Number on a Credit Card Statement Mean?, Pocketsense, 27 October 2018.
- "UK economy shrank at end of 2012". 25 January 2013. Retrieved 5 December 2018 – via www.bbc.co.uk.
- "First negative inflation figure since 1960". The Independent. 21 April 2009. Retrieved 5 December 2018.
- "ECB imposes negative interest rate". BBC News. 5 June 2014. Retrieved 5 December 2018.
- Lynn, Matthew. "Think negative interest rates can't happen here? Think again". MarketWatch. Retrieved 5 December 2018.
- "Swiss interest rate to turn negative". BBC News. 18 December 2014. Retrieved 5 December 2018.
- Wintour, Patrick (17 June 2014). "Popularity of Miliband and Clegg falls to lowest levels recorded by ICM poll". Retrieved 5 December 2018 – via www.theguardian.com.
- Grant P. Wiggins; Jay McTighe (2005). Understanding by design. ACSD Publications. p. 210. ISBN 1-4166-0035-3.
- Needham, Joseph; Wang, Ling (1995) . Science and Civilisation in China: Volume 3; Mathematics and the Sciences of the Heavens and the Earth (reprint ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. p. 90. ISBN 0-521-05801-5.
- Heath, Thomas L. (1897). The works of Archimedes. Cambridge University Press. pp. cxxiii.
- Needham, Joseph; Wang, Ling (1995) . Science and Civilisation in China: Volume 3; Mathematics and the Sciences of the Heavens and the Earth (reprint ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 90–91. ISBN 0-521-05801-5.
- Teresi, Dick. (2002). Lost Discoveries: The Ancient Roots of Modern Science–from the Babylonians to the Mayas. New York: Simon & Schuster. ISBN 0-684-83718-8. Page 65.
- Pearce, Ian (May 2002). "The Bakhshali manuscript". The MacTutor History of Mathematics archive. Retrieved 24 July 2007.
- Takao Hayashi (2008), "Bakhshālī Manuscript", in Helaine Selin (ed.), Encyclopaedia of the History of Science, Technology, and Medicine in Non-Western Cultures, 1, Springer, p. B2, ISBN 9781402045592
- Teresi, Dick. (2002). Lost Discoveries: The Ancient Roots of Modern Science–from the Babylonians to the Mayas. New York: Simon & Schuster. ISBN 0-684-83718-8. Page 65–66.
- Colva M. Roney-Dougal, Lecturer in Pure Mathematics at the University of St Andrews, stated this on the BBC Radio 4 programme "In Our Time," on 9 March 2006.
- Knowledge Transfer and Perceptions of the Passage of Time, ICEE-2002 Keynote Address by Colin Adamson-Macedo. "Referring again to Brahmagupta's great work, all the necessary rules for algebra, including the 'rule of signs', were stipulated, but in a form which used the language and imagery of commerce and the market place. Thus 'dhana' (= fortunes) is used to represent positive numbers, whereas 'rina' (= debts) were negative".
- Mat Rofa Bin Ismail (2008), "Algebra in Islamic Mathematics", in Helaine Selin (ed.), Encyclopaedia of the History of Science, Technology, and Medicine in Non-Western Cultures, 1 (2nd ed.), Springer, p. 115, ISBN 9781402045592
- Martinez, Alberto (2014). Negative Math. Princeton University Press. pp. 80–109.
- Martinez, Alberto A. (2006). Negative Math: How Mathematical Rules Can Be Positively Bent. Princeton University Press. a history of controversies on negative numbers, mainly from the 1600s until the early 1900s.
- Maseres, Francis (1758). A dissertation on the use of the negative sign in algebra: containing a demonstration of the rules usually given concerning it; and shewing how quadratic and cubic equations may be explained, without the consideration of negative roots. To which is added, as an appendix, Mr. Machin's Quadrature of the Circle. Quoting from Maseres' work: If any single quantity is marked either with the sign + or the sign − without affecting some other quantity, the mark will have no meaning or significance, thus if it be said that the square of −5, or the product of −5 into −5, is equal to +25, such an assertion must either signify no more than 5 times 5 is equal to 25 without any regard for the signs, or it must be mere nonsense or unintelligible jargon.
- Flegg, Graham; Hay, C.; Moss, B. (1985), Nicolas Chuquet, Renaissance Mathematician: a study with extensive translations of Chuquet's mathematical manuscript completed in 1484, D. Reidel Publishing Co., p. 354, ISBN 9789027718723.
- Famous Problems and Their Mathematicians, Greenwood Publishing Group, 1999, p. 56, ISBN 9781563084461.
- Bourbaki, Nicolas (1998). Elements of the History of Mathematics. Berlin, Heidelberg, and New York: Springer-Verlag. ISBN 3-540-64767-8.
- Struik, Dirk J. (1987). A Concise History of Mathematics. New York: Dover Publications.
|Wikiquote has quotations related to: Negative number|