What is the effect of impedance on headphone sound quality?

43

10

Headphones come in various different impedance levels, such as 8, 16 and 32 Ohms. The power supplied by the audio source can be at different levels due to a variety of factors such as being limited due to being battery powered. At lower power levels, lower impedance in the headphones can allow higher volume levels (sensitivity being equal).

From my basic electrical engineering courses, my instinct is that higher impedance headphones would also create a more level frequency response, thus being more true to the original signal. Is this true?

In relation to achieving optimal sound quality, is there any advantage to pairing high-impedance headphones with an amplifier if the audio source has a lower power level rather than simply using low-impedance headphones?

Cory Klein

Posted 2011-01-20T18:44:51.023

Reputation: 585

3Weirdly enough, changing the number of turns of wire in a electromagnet doesn't change the magnetic field. Field is proportional to number of turns × current, so if you double the number of turns, you're also doubling the resistance and therefore halving the current, which means no net change. You're wasting less heat energy to produce the same magnetic field (which I think means higher sensitivity/efficiency). – endolith – 2012-10-08T21:41:07.527

Very interesting. In my small experience I think that "AKG K141 Monitor" (1980-1990) are the best I have "listened to" so far. The high impedance (600 ohm) is still useable on my pc at full volume on my Soundblaster X-fi. I was wondering if lower impedance (55 ohm) headphones from AKG would have the same "uncolored" sound that the K141 Monitor have. I will go and test some. – None – 2013-05-27T13:46:54.297

Answers

24

High-impedance headphones are designed for studio-like applications where there may be multiple phones wired in parallel receiving an input signal from one source. Low-impedance headphones are designed to be plugged directly into a single source, and can more effeciently generate sound from the lower level input signal.

High-impedance headphones are a little more durable (electronically), but require higher signal levels to produce the same output level of low-impedance headphones.

BenV

Posted 2011-01-20T18:44:51.023

Reputation: 3 595

Multiple units wired in parallel? Wouldn't that short-circuit them? – None – 2011-11-24T12:33:38.787

@Gauthier: No, it puts them in parallel. The total impedance drops, but not to zero. Putting 2 headphones in parallel halves the impedance. – endolith – 2012-10-09T21:36:45.227

High-Z headphones are intended for use with passive mixers? – ObscureRobot – 2012-10-10T12:48:02.617

@endolith: headphones, yes. But this answer says "receiving an input signal from multiple units wired in parallel", I interpret "units" as units with output, not headphones. If one unit's output want 1V while another one wants 0V, and they are connected... that's a SC. Where do I misunderstand? – None – 2012-10-11T13:26:30.950

@Gauthier: Oh, I see. No, despite the wording, it's multiple headphones in parallel with a single source. :) "Phones in this impedance range may be directly plugged into the headphone jack routinely found on recording and playback equipment. Higher impedances, such as 600 ohms, are more useful in studio installations where many units may be wired in parallel for studio monitoring applications." http://www.akg.com/site/product_tipps/powerslave,id,35,nodeid,2,_language,EN.html

– endolith – 2012-10-11T13:44:06.690

Yeah, I'm with you. Editing the answer for clarity was needed, good that you did that. – None – 2012-10-12T09:17:02.360

This does not answer the question – Andy Ray – 2018-02-18T03:47:29.263

16

The power required to operate headphones is a function of the driver size and mass, whether the phones are open, closed, or in-ear, etc. The impedance of headphones is usually designed to get an acceptable volume level (power = voltage^2 / impedance) at the voltage level expected on the driving equipment. It's not necessarily a straightforward relationship of low impedance = cheap, high-impedance = pro.

Many really fine headphones have large drivers (more power), are open-air (more power), AND expect to be run from higher-voltage professional/amplified equipment... which sort of cancels out the impedance question from a design perspective. Apple earbuds are 23 ohms... my fave studio headphones, Audio-Technica ATH-M50s, are 38 ohms... one of the most common studio headphones, Sony MDR7506, are 63 ohms. So, more "pro" headphones are higher impedance, but that just means that you will get less power (lower volume) on a low-voltage audio source.

There are other good reasons to use an external amplifier... RF/EMI noise isolation, etc... but I think the main reason you might want to with better headphones is that the volume may be low with higher-impedance headphones.

Bill Gribble

Posted 2011-01-20T18:44:51.023

Reputation:

4I think the key to my question lies in this part: "expect to be run from higher-voltage professional/amplified equipment". Everywhere I look, people say high impedance headphones are that way to match the high voltage amplifiers, and the amplifier people say they provide high voltage to power your high impedance headphones! It seems that the loop needs to stop somewhere, and it appears to me that there is a reasoning behind creating pro headphones with high impedance from 250-600 ohms. – None – 2011-01-21T21:39:30.950

1@Cory: There is one kind of headphones that nobody has mentioned yet, and that is electrostatic headphones. Electrostatics are the only high-fidelity headphones that I would consider truly "high-impedance." The sound quality of electrostatics is unparalleled. But electrostatics are quite exotic; they require special high-voltage amplifiers, and are generally very expensive. – Robert Harvey – 2011-01-25T18:23:58.833

"higher impedance → less power (lower volume)"? I don't think that follows, as you're not including sensitivity. Headphones convert electrical energy into sound energy and heat energy. A headphone generating more heat does not necessarily generate more sound. – endolith – 2012-10-08T21:17:09.803

1

@Cory: "it appears to me that there is a reasoning behind creating pro headphones with high impedance" It reduces distortion, for one. See http://nwavguy.blogspot.com/2011/02/headphone-impedance-explained.html

– endolith – 2015-06-25T01:53:21.393

1@endolith Great website info there. I'm surpised nobody bothered to add some of the info from there. E.g. SPL, sensitivity and calculations etc. – not2qubit – 2020-04-22T10:26:23.350

So far, the best discussion on this subject, not already mentioned here, is this.

– not2qubit – 2020-04-22T10:56:04.527

15

Snagged from Beyer-Dynamics website:

The impedance is determined by the voice coil (dynamic headphones), which is a winded copper wire (coated to avoid a short-circuit). This copper wire is available in nearly every length, but not in every gauge (thickness) and a thicker wire has less resistance than a thin wire ("less fits through"). The magnetic field of the voice coil depends on the number of windings of the coil, causing a low impedance system to use a thicker (also heavier) wire and since the membrane foil can't be infinitely light-weight, the moving mass (voice coil and diaphragm) is relatively high. It's pretty clear that a higher mass can't move as easily (following an audio signal) as a lower mass. This low mass can easily be accomplished with thinner (lower weight) wire, but the thinner wire has a higher impedance. This means that the DT 770 PRO with 250 ohms sound more natural, but plays (depending on the used headphone amplifier) not as loud as the 80 ohms version.

The transducers of the 80 ohms versions are stronger and more powerful, a bit more low-mid accentuated and therefore this version is ideal for powerful reproducing of low-frequency material f.e. coming from a bass guitar. The 250 ohms version sounds more smooth and voluminous and can be used for mixing situations within the studio to analyse the whole mix.

christiancoriolis

Posted 2011-01-20T18:44:51.023

Reputation: 596

1Could you please add a link back to your source and/or summarize the post in your own words? – AJ Henderson – 2014-06-23T22:26:16.100

Errr...it's here, under the tab "Different impedances": http://europe.beyerdynamic.com/service/faqs.html I don't think I can say it better myself though ;-)

– christiancoriolis – 2014-06-25T06:52:09.107

4

In relation to achieving optimal sound quality, is there any advantage to pairing high-impedance headphones with an amplifier for listening on an MP3 player or laptop, as opposed to just using low-impedance headphones?

Yes, there is. In fact, there is an advantage to using an external amplifier for any headphones.

If you are resourceful, you could try building a CMOY amp in an Altoids box, like the picture below. The sound is awesome, and the cool factor is off the scale.

alt text

Why do amps like this improve the sound? I could talk about slew rate, total harmonic distortion and a whole host of other factors, but the simple fact is that having a booster amp like this means that your original amplifier doesn't have to work as hard. Most small audio output (including the headphone amps in the vast majority of computers and laptops) only produce about 100 milliwatts of power, and that's just not enough to insure high fidelity.

Here's how impedance affects the performance of headphones: a lower impedance allows headphones to capture more power from the amplifier. All other things being equal, they are going to be louder than headphones with a higher impedance, because higher impedance requires a higher voltage level from the amplifier to achieve the same relative loudness. This is why earbuds typically have a much lower impedance than other headphones; it is necessary to get adequate volume, given the low voltages provided by batteries.

Robert Harvey

Posted 2011-01-20T18:44:51.023

Reputation: 1 251

Can you explain in what way high impedance headphones are superior? Why not just have low-impedance headphones with an amplifier? – None – 2011-01-21T21:41:07.607

2@Cory: I don't think high-impedance headphones are superior just because they're high-impedance. Their overall design is what makes them good headphones. – Robert Harvey – 2011-01-25T00:44:50.183

I agree that just making some headphones high impedance isn't a catch-all to make them good headphones. But does the high-impedance contribute to superior headphones creating high fidelity sound? – None – 2011-01-25T18:14:45.510

@Cory: I don't see how; as long as your amplifier can handle the current needs of low-impedance headphones, it comes down to the quality of the headphone design. – Robert Harvey – 2011-01-25T18:19:58.823

You say there's an advantage to an external headphone amp, but don't mention what it is? – endolith – 2012-10-08T21:13:16.580

1This seems more like a product recommendation than an answer to the question. – ObscureRobot – 2013-05-27T20:34:55.310

1@ObscureRobot: The amplifier itself is the answer to the question. Is there an advantage? Yes; otherwise amps like this wouldn't exist. It's not a product endorsement; there are many such amps out there that will do the same job. This one just happens to be one that you don't have to buy; you can obtain the parts and build it yourself. However, since two people have now asked for additional explanations, I will make an attempt to do so. – Robert Harvey – 2013-05-27T21:35:53.210

No, it still isn't an answer to the question. Lamborghinis exist, but what question do they answer? – ObscureRobot – 2013-05-27T22:57:21.667

Incidentally, I'm probably a bigger fan of DIY solutions than most people here. But even your added paragraph doesn't address the issue of how impedance impacts headphone quality. – ObscureRobot – 2013-05-27T22:59:25.787

@ObscureRobot: Impedance, all by itself, doesn't impact headphone quality at all. However, see my additional edit. This is pretty pedestrian stuff; anyone with a little curiosity can find it out with a little study, or even some casual observation. – Robert Harvey – 2013-05-28T03:25:43.927

@Cory: "But does the high-impedance contribute to superior headphones creating high fidelity sound?" Yes, headphone amplifiers distort less when driving high impedances, and high-impedance headphones are less affected by the output impedance of the amp. It is a trade-off between sound level and sound quality. Battery-powered devices can't supply as much level, so they use low-impedance headphones with poorer performance to get it back up to usable volume. – endolith – 2015-06-25T01:56:55.503

(...and make sure the op-amp in your CMoy amplifier is designed to drive headphone impedances with low distortion. The ones I've seen recommended with it are not appropriate choices, which is why people hear differences between op-amps that should behave identically.) – endolith – 2015-06-25T02:02:13.440

4

An amplifier works by multiplying the voltage of your audio source(CD, TV, etc...). When this voltage is applied to a load, such as a pair of headphones, then a current runs though the pair of headphones in relation to V=IZ where Z is the impedance. An ideal amp would maintain the exact same voltage regardless if the load is connected or not. However realistically the current causes a drop in voltage which leads to a different current then the one that was intended, this results in distortion. A set of high impedance headphones draws less current then low impedance headphones and therefore doesn't change the signal from the amp as much, which means lower distortion. This change in voltage is associated with a figure called the 'damping factor' which is the ratio of the headphone impedance with the output impedance of the amp.

Of course damping factor can also be improved by lowering the output impedance instead of increasing headphone impedance. However you can only push an amp as long as it can supply current. If you were to continue to lower the impedance Z you reach a point where you really can't get anymore current and wave cuts off. This cutoff is called clipping and it is a serious form of distortion. A high impedance headphone has an advantage in this case as well because of the higher impedance means a lower current draw and delays the onset of clipping.

The downside of high impedance headphones is the lower output for the same voltage. This is really only an issue if the sound level seems way too low even on max volume. In this case you need a more powerful amp to drive the headphones. Along with a limited amount of current, amps also have a maximum voltage they can reach. If you have a low powered amp with high gain then you could reach this maximum which would result in clipping again.

Just play close attention to the specs of your amp and headphones and you can avoid many of these issues.

cspirou

Posted 2011-01-20T18:44:51.023

Reputation: 268

1

It seems that the ratio of source impedance to headphone impedance, i.e. damping factor is primarily discussed in terms of effect on amplitude and frequency response. In addition, remember that a higher impedance circuit will likely exhibit a reduced slew rate and slower rise time. This will effect the clarity and openness of the sound and possibly dull transit response.

kpotter

Posted 2011-01-20T18:44:51.023

Reputation:

Running into slew rate limits would cause distortion – endolith – 2015-06-25T01:59:06.600

-1

Consider the difference between consumer and line level:

You need to match the impedance in order to preserve the condition of the gear, but pro line level (+4 dbu) is a hotter signal than consumer (-10 dbv). The reason that professional monitors use the hotter signal, is because it is higher fidelity.

I assume that the same applies to headphones. you get a wider dynamic range and more clarity in softer dynamics when you have a wider spectrum of amplitude, which is the property of the signal propagating through your resistors and cable.

ezcheese1

Posted 2011-01-20T18:44:51.023

Reputation: