Who voted for anonymity in the vote on transparency in the European Parliament?

8

1

Today the 31st of January 2019 there was a vote in the European Parliament on the topic of transparency with regards to contacts with lobbyists (link in swedish). This vote was decided to be cast anonymously, which can be done if more than one fifth of the MEP's want to.

Who voted for having an anonymous vote? Official sources are a great plus.

I cannot find the vote at the European Parliament web page.

VoteWatch.eu as suggested in another answer gives a 502 error, so this is not an option.

Hektor-Waartgard

Posted 2019-01-31T17:14:23.143

Reputation: 83

What was the result? – M i ech – 2019-02-04T08:56:42.000

The result of which vote? – Hektor-Waartgard – 2019-02-05T10:22:06.013

2The vote for transparency passed. The EVP is furios. – miep – 2019-02-05T11:34:25.450

Answers

9

According to this source (German newspaper), the German part of the EVP (CDU/CSU) voted for anonymous votes. Which isn't surprising, as this party tends to favor companies who coincidentally gifted large amounts of money to them. They have absolutely no interest in people knowing who's paying them how much and who visits them how often. Neither in Germany nor in the EU.

One case of this here (also German newspaper, but I think it's hard to find English sources to a mainly German topic.)

EDIT: This problem is sometimes referred to as "legal corruption" and is, depending on who you're asking, either completely fine (because it's legal) or a democratic disaster (as those politicians are effectively bought).

An English source here

miep

Posted 2019-01-31T17:14:23.143

Reputation: 987

Thanks for the answer. This answers it nicely from a German perspective. But what about MEP's from Greece, Netherlands, or any other country? Is there no official source where I can see all votes, without having to go through local newspapers of every member country? – Hektor-Waartgard – 2019-02-05T10:21:41.980

Your sources (votewatch and the EP web-page) would be the best for this. If they can't help you, it will be difficult. But the German CDU is very powerful so I'm sure they convinced other members of the EVP to vote for this, too. As said, they have influential "sponsors" which surely will back their "argument" up. – miep – 2019-02-05T11:18:29.980

I found some other sources which simply say "the conservatives" which probably means the EVP. – miep – 2019-02-05T11:35:53.627

Did some more research and well... All are saying "conservatives", "German conservatives" or "CDU" so yes, the CDU was the main factor here. – miep – 2019-02-05T11:41:04.070