Y-DNA match a false positive?

6

I completed a Family Tree DNA test for Y-DNA. My results show I have only six matches. I have viewed the available trees of 4 of the 6 trees, the others are private and unwilling to cooperate. I cannot find any matches but unsure if the Y-DNA is giving me a false positive if that is possible. If I were to compare X-DNA and Y-DNA, would that give me a more accurate rendering of DNA matches? Actually. I am not sure such a comparison is possible.

I am a newbie at using DNA as a resource for finding my ancestral surname family. I am trying to find Farrell family beyond my great grandfather. Any suggestions or corrections to my interpretation of my Y-DNA results.

Rod Farrell

Posted 2016-09-19T15:08:32.167

Reputation: 61

Hi, welcome to G&FH.SE! Please take a moment to take the [tour] and to look at the [help] to review our site guidelines. The purpose of the site is to create answers and answers that will be of general interest, using our case studies as examples -- not simply to post personal queries for people to answer off-site. I have removed your signature because the site signs all your posts with your user card. If you would like to leave your email for others to contact you, you may put it in your profile. – Jan Murphy – 2016-09-19T15:36:26.347

2Comparing X-DNA and Y-DNA is not meaningful. Can you explain why you think the Y-DNA matches are a false positive? How close are the matches? What level of Y testing have you done (how many markers). If you can illustrate the question with some real (anonymised data) that would be helpful. – None – 2016-09-19T15:45:59.237

Answers

6

It is extremely rare for Y-DNA analysis to give a false positive. However, the people you match to may connect 10, 20, or 30 generations back which is likely not genealogically relevant since you won't find records that far back to determine who the common ancestor is.

If you've only gone back to your great-grandfather, you should take an autosomal (or Family Finder) test, which will find probable relatives on all your sides out to about 5th or 6th cousins. You can see if any of them have your Farrell surname among their ancestors or in their tree which may be on any of their lines, not just their male line which the Y-DNA test determines.

The X chromosome will not help you much. You might think you can eliminate people with an X match because they won't be on your father's side, but you never know because people can be related to you in multiple ways, and one of those other ways might be through your father's side.

lkessler

Posted 2016-09-19T15:08:32.167

Reputation: 16 148