Can the Bitcoin system be changed?


Are we stuck with what is here now? or if 10 years down the road serious changes need to be made to the system; can that be done with a decentralized system? How would you make changes to a decentralized system like this?


Posted 2013-03-29T05:45:27.187

Reputation: 81

1Not to be pedantic, but Bitcoin is distributed, not decentralized. There's a significant difference between the two terms. – Colin Dean – 2013-03-29T15:23:59.173

Centralized, but the party with the central control can (and normally will) change every ten minutes -- essentially randomly, in terms of per-unit of computational strength. That's close enough that calling it decentralized is OK in my book. – Stephen Gornick – 2013-03-30T05:42:34.273



The power to change the Bitcoin protocol depends on the willingness of the economic majority to adopt the changes.

A wishlist exists of some changes that have been considered.

If the change is one that devalues the currency, then those who hold coins or plan to hold them in the future will be less willing to adopt the change(s). Some suggestions have been discussed and rejected so many times that a separate list of prohibited change suggestions has been compiled. If the change is one that improves Bitcoin without devaluing the currency or harming it some other way, those changes could be adopted. If the change is not really necessary it might not be adopted, especially if there is the possibility for unintended consequences to be the result.

Stephen Gornick

Posted 2013-03-29T05:45:27.187

Reputation: 26 454


A decentralized system can be changed, yes, if the majority of users using the system start using a changed client or the changed client is backward-compatible. The Bitcoin 0.8 upgrade caused some problems, as not everybody upgraded and 0.8 had a bug in which everybody needed to upgrade.


Posted 2013-03-29T05:45:27.187

Reputation: 116