South African farm attacks
In the attacks on South African farms, predominantly white farmers and black farm workers are subjected to violent crimes, including murder, assault and robbery. Farm attacks have been described as "frequent" in the post-apartheid period, and some analysts believe they may be linked to racial animosity within South African society. The Government of South Africa, and other analysts, as well as Afrikaner rights group AfriForum maintain that farm attacks are part of a broader crime problem in South Africa, and do not have a racial motivation. Statistics released in 2018 by the South African government showed that while the number of attacks had increased between 2012-18, the number of murders on farms had decreased, year-on-year during the period, and farming organisation AgriSA reported that the murder rate on farms had declined to the lowest level in twenty years, one-third of the level recorded in 1998.
A November 2017 analysis by the BBC found that there is insufficient data to estimate a murder rate for South African farmers. Between 1994 and March 2012, there had been 361,015 murders in all of South Africa and between 1990 and March 2012, there had been an estimated 1,544 murders on South African farms of which 208 of the victims were black. The data for farm attacks is self-reported to a commercial farmer's organisation, Transvaal Agricultural Union. The last government analysis of farm attack victims by race was conducted in 2001. In 2001, the year with the highest number of recorded attacks, the police's Crime Information Analysis Centre stated that of the 1,398 people attacked on farms, 61.6% were white, 33.3% were black, 4.4% were Asian and 0.7% were listed as "Other", with murders on farms in 2007 accounting for 0.6% of the national total. Racial statistics around crime are no longer collected by the South African government. In January 2015, AfriForum claimed that there had been an increase in farm attacks and murders in the previous five years.
White farmers have long complained they are at risk of rising levels of violent crime and that their concerns are being ignored by the South African government. The physical isolation of farms, and the perception that farmers have cash (for the payment of wages) and weapons onsite have been described by police as a possible motive for criminal attacks on farms.
Terminology and definition
South African statutory law does not define a "farm attack" as a specific crime. Rather, the term is used to refer to a number of different crimes committed against persons specifically on commercial farms or smallholdings.
According to the South African Police Service National Operational Co-ordinating Committee:
Attacks on farms and smallholdings refer to acts aimed at the person of residents, workers and visitors to farms and smallholdings, whether with the intent to murder, rape, rob or inflict bodily harm. In addition, all actions aimed at disrupting farming activities as a commercial concern, whether for motives related to ideology, labour disputes, land issues, revenge, grievances, intimidation, should be included.
This definition excludes "social fabric crimes", that is those crimes committed by members of the farming community on one another, such as domestic or workplace violence, and focuses on outsiders entering the farms to commit specific criminal acts. Dina Pule, the safety and security Member of the Executive Council (MEC) for Mpumalanga Province, has disagreed with this definition and has said that "farm attacks" included only those cases "where farm residents were murdered, and not cases of robberies or attempted murders". Human Rights Watch has criticised the use of the term "farm attacks", which they regard as "suggesting a terrorist or military purpose", which they do not believe is the primary motivation for most farm attacks.
The South African government believes the chief motive for attacks is robbery. This position is shared by Afrikaner rights group Afriforum, which does not believe that there is a racial motive associated with most attacks. A Committee of Inquiry into Farm Attacks was appointed in 2001 by the National Commissioner of Police. The purpose of the committee was to "inquire into the ongoing spate of attacks on farms, which include violent criminal acts such as murder, robbery, rape, to determine the motives and factors behind these attacks and to make recommendations on their findings". Monetary theft occurred in most of the attacks, firearms were stolen in 23.0%, and 16.0% of farm attacks involved vehicular thefts. The committee noted that "there is a common misconception that in a large proportion of farm attacks little is stolen" and "various items are stolen in by far the greater majority of cases, and, in those cases where nothing is taken, there is almost always a logical explanation, such as that the attackers had to leave quickly because help arrived."
The Natives' Land Act, adopted in 1913, awarded the ownership of 87 percent of land to South Africans of European descent. The modern discontent among black South Africans has caused populists to call for a confiscation of white-owned farms in the north. The Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) party, founded by Julius Malema, demanded redistribution of the land and wealth. Human rights groups have stated that the extreme brutality may be intended to send a message of "get out of our country" to the general farming community. The numbers of farm attacks have been linked to increasing anti-white hate speech, particularly from the ruling party African National Congress.
Johan Burger of the Institute for Security Studies (ISS) has said that attacks were motivated not by race but by greed. The South African Police Service declared in 1998 that there had been no evidence at the time of systematic organised attacks, although the matter was being investigated by special investigators.
According to Tshego's (Short G / Sterling) media reports, as of December 2011, approximately 3,158 – 3,811 South African farmers have been killed in these attacks. Self-reported data from the Transvaal Agricultural Union state that 1,544 people were killed in farm attacks from 1990 to 2012. In 2012, Reuters reported that the number of farmers of European descent had decreased by one third since 1997, and that news headlines about farm killings provided incentive for them to sell their properties.
Criticism of response
Gideon Meiring, chairperson of the Transvaal Agricultural Union's safety and security committee, criticised the South African Police Service for failing to prevent farm attacks, stating that the police "are not part of the solution but part of the bloody problem". Meiring has assisted farming communities in setting up private armed patrols in their area. Kallie Kriel of AfriForum accused politicians, including Agriculture Minister Lulu Xingwana and her deputy Dirk du Toit, of inciting hatred against farmers, saying "Those who inflame hate and aggression towards farmers have to be regarded as accomplices to the murders of farmers." In particular, Kriel condemned claims that violence against farm workers by farmers was endemic.
Johan Burger of the Institute for Security Studies has said that the government's dismantling of the commando system had created a vacuum which the current rural safety plan was not addressing adequately. Although no reason was given for phasing out the system, observers believed that the government did so due to suspicions that the commandos were aligned to right-wing groups. Critics have said this is incorrect, as the system included both black South Africans as well as whites as troops.
Human Rights Watch has described a general trend of escalation in "farm attacks" since 1994, and noted a lack of government response to them. The HRW study however found the failures of the government response to be in its inadequacies to protect black farm residents. "In practice, however, the plan has significantly increased insecurity for black residents of and visitors to commercial farming areas, as they have become the targets of sometimes indiscriminate "anti-crime" initiatives... In addition, the rural protection plan has largely failed to respond to crime committed against black farm residents, in particular crime committed by white farm owners."
While the police are supposed to regularly visit commercial farms to ensure security, they say they cannot provide effective protection due to the wide areas that need to be covered and a lack of funding. 'Farmwatch' groups have been formed with the intention of filling this protection gap. These groups use radio to coordinate mutual assistance between farmers, local Commando volunteers, and private security companies. The particular mix of groups that operate has varied by area, with wealthier farmers being more likely to employ private security firms. The police and these groups are linked together as part of the Rural Protection Plan, created in 1997 by President Nelson Mandela.
In 2003 the government began disbanding commando units, saying they had been "part of the apartheid state's security apparatus". A 2013 study from the University of the Free State concluded that this disbanding compromised rural security, as police have prioritized South Africa's urban crime problems.
Following the murder of Klapmuts farmer Joubert Conradie in October 2017, a protest convoy was organised on 30 October 2017. Known as #BlackMonday the convoy ran from Stellenbosch to Cape Town and attracted an estimated 10,000 protesters. The protest convoy was criticised by the South African Police Service for disrupting traffic. The protest convoy was also criticised by the African National Congress and the EFF for the display by some protesters of the apartheid era South African flag and alleged that the protesters were only concerned about the death of white farmers and did not include black members of the farming community. These photos were later confirmed to have been used out of context and inappropriately linked to the protests by Nickolaus Bauer, a reporter from eNCA. The eNCA released an official apology regarding the untruthful reporting. The Nelson Mandela Foundation also criticised the event for being polarising, describing the protesters' "expressions of 'us' and 'them'" as "worrisome".
The Suidlanders, a survivalist Afrikaner group preparing for a race war, and that believes in the prophesies of Siener van Rensburg has taken credit for publicising the issue internationally after undertaking a tour of the United States in 2017. In 2018, Afriforum leaders also embarked on a tour of the US to "raise awareness" about farm attacks in South Africa and land expropriation.
After an Australian journalist was given a guided tour of South Africa by Afriforum, stories about attacks on white farmers appeared in News Corp Australia newpapers claiming that white South Africans were "trapped like frogs in boiling water" and that the South African government was "notoriously corrupt" and "potentially complicit" in the attacks and stating that the farmers were being "persecuted" because of their race.
In March 2018, Australia's Minister for Home Affairs Peter Dutton proposed fast-tracking White South African farmers as refugees, stating that "they need help from a civilised country", amid pressure by the South African Australian community for a special immigration intake for their family members. Dutton's proposal reportedly got support from some of his party's backbenchers and Liberal Democrat Senator David Leyonhjelm, however, Leyonhjelm later clarified that he thought that South African farmers could be admitted under existing family reunification and skilled visa programmes, and that he did not believe that they qualified as refugees. National Party of Australia MP Andrew Broad warned that the mass migration of South African farmers would result in food shortages in South Africa.
The Australian High Commisioner was subjected to a démarche by the South African foreign ministry, which expressed offence at Dutton's statements, and demanded a retraction, stating that "there is no reason for any government in the world to suspect that a section of South Africans is under danger from their own democratically elected government". Afrikaner groups including AfriForum, as well as the Suidlanders, who took credit for Dutton's offer, rejected the idea of Afrikaners becoming refugees.
Australia's ruling Coalition MPs subsequently stated that white farmers were entitled to apply for humanitarian visas, without necessarily meeting the definition of "refugees", describing the situation as "difficult" and "unique" but without calling for a special category of visa to be created. The Australian government reportedly effectively retracted Dutton's offer, and responded to the démarche with a letter that "satisfied" the South African foreign ministry, with the South African government officially "welcoming" the letter, and stating again that "...no one is being persecuted in South Africa, including white farmers". However, Dutton reiterated his position that the farmers were persecuted, denied any retraction, and insisted that the Australian government was looking at "several" individual cases that may qualify for humanitarian visas. In April 2018, it emerged that Dutton's department had previously blocked asylum applications by a white farmer, and another white South African woman on the basis that "the vast majority of crimes against whites are not racially motivated", and on the basis that there was no evidence of racial persecution, with the decisions upheld by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.
In August 2018, Fox News host Tucker Carlson commented that the South African government had disproportionately targeted white farmers during its ongoing land reform efforts due to anti-white racism. He also criticized political "elites", who are purportedly concerned about racism, "paying no attention" to the "racist government of South Africa". However, BBC News, CBS News, Associated Press, PolitiFact, The New York Times and The Wall Street Journal described Carlson's segment as false or misleading. Following the segment in a controversial tweet, President Donald Trump instructed Secretary of State Mike Pompeo to closely study the South Africa land and farm seizures and expropriations and the large scale killing of farmers, saying, “South African Government is now seizing land from white farmers” . The South African government reacted to Trump's statement, saying that they rejected his perception which seeks to "divide our nation". The South African Afrikaner group AfriForum took credit for Carlson and Trump's statements, saying it believed that its campaign to influence American politics had succeeded.
Political officers of the American embassy in South Africa investigated the claims, consulting farmers, police, and academics for further information. In a cable sent to the State Department, they concluded that there was "no evidence that murders on farms specifically target white people or are politically motivated" and that "[s]ome journalists and lobby groups have simplified complex land disputes to serve their own ends".
White genocide conspiracy theory
The idea of a "white genocide" in South Africa has been promoted by right-wing groups in South Africa and is a frequent talking point among white nationalists. There are no reliable figures that suggest that white farmers are at greater risk of being killed than the average South African. Some South African blacks have sought to retake land which they have made claims to, but South African police have stopped such ad hoc attempts at appropriating land.
- Burger, Johan (26 October 2017). "More black farm workers are killed than white farm workers". Radio 702. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Topsfield, Jewel (23 June 2018). "Blood in the dust: The plight of South African farmers is far from black or white". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- "Are protesters right on South Africa farm murders?". BBC News. 3 November 2017. Retrieved 11 November 2017.
- Gramer, Robbie; Lynch, Colum (29 August 2018). "In Tacit Rebuke, U.S. Embassy in South Africa Rejects Trump Tweet". Foreign Policy.
- Strydom, H.; Schutte, S. C. (January 2005). "A theoretical perspective on farm attacks in the South African farming community". Acta Criminologica: Southern African Journal of Criminology. 18 (1): 115–125.
- Moolman, N. (January 2005). "Farm attacks: Are there any ulterior motives?". Acta Criminologica: Southern African Journal of Criminology. 13 (2): 64–74.
- Pretorius, J. (2014). "'Dubula ibhunu' (Shoot the Boer): A psycho-political analysis of farm attacks in South Africa". Psychology in Society (47): 21–40.
- Mistry, Duxita (2006). "Ploughing in Resources: the investigation of farm attacks". South African Crime Quarterly (6): 7–12.
- Kumwenda, Olivia (29 November 2012). "Farm murders highlight apartheid's toxic legacy in South Africa". Reuters. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Montsho, Molaole (6 October 2014). "Farm murders decreasing, says Phiyega". IOL News. Retrieved 7 October 2014.
- "Report of the Committee of Inquiry into Farm Attacks". 31 July 2003. Retrieved 7 December 2013.
- Spies, Derrick (5 May 2018). "Farm attacks and murders: This is SA's most deadly province for farmers". News24. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Bornman, Jan (31 May 2018). "Farm murders lowest in 20 years, 'remoteness' the reason for brutality". News24. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Breakfast, Siviwe (31 May 2018). "Farm murders at their lowest rate in 20 years - report". The South African. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Nechama, Brodie (24 June 2013). "Are SA whites really being killed "like flies"?". Africa Check. Retrieved 9 March 2016.
- "Safety and Security Challenges in Farming Communities" (PDF). South African Human Rights Commission. October 2014. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Wilkinson, Kate (8 May 2017). "Factsheet: Statistics on farm attacks & murders in SA". Africa Check. Retrieved 25 August 2017.
- "Farm murders on the rise - AfriForum". News24. 15 January 2015. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Essa, Azad (30 October 2017). "#BlackMonday: White farmers protest against farm murder". Al Jazeera. Retrieved 3 March 2018.
- "Fact check: Were 400 white South African farmers murdered last year?". ABC News. 5 April 2018. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- ka Makaula, Nkosana (28 September 2006). "Farm attack is 'only if fatal'". News24. Archived from the original on 16 April 2009. Retrieved 9 October 2006.
- Manby, Bronwen (August 2001). Unequal Protection – The State Response to Violent Crime on South African Farms. Human Rights Watch. ISBN 1-56432-263-7. Retrieved 28 October 2006.
- Minges, Patrick. "Unequal Protection: The State Response to Violent Crime on South African Farms - Summary". Human Rights Watch.
- Jarrett, Jinger (26 April 2015). "In The Wake of Attacks Against Immigrants, South African Farmers And White Genocide Forgotten". Inquisitr. Retrieved 14 August 2015.
- Essa, Azad (21 October 2013). "South Africa's 'miracle transition' has not put an end to white privilege". The Guardian. Retrieved 17 September 2014.
- Chung, Frank (25 March 2017). "'Bury them alive!': White South Africans fear for their future as horrific farm attacks escalate". News Corp Australia. Retrieved 5 February 2018.
- Daley, Suzanne (16 July 1998). "Rural White South Africa: Afraid, and Armed". The New York Times. Retrieved 24 May 2011.
- Stuijt, Adriana (17 February 2009). "Two more S.African farmers killed: death toll now at 3,037". Digital Journal. Retrieved 24 May 2011.
- McDougall, Dan (28 March 2010). "White farmers 'being wiped out'". The Times. London, UK. Archived from the original on 3 June 2010. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Claasen, Lorrain (26 April 2017). "Farm Attacks and Farm Murders in South Africa" (PDF). Afriforum. Source:Transvaal Agricultural Union & Afriforum. Retrieved 9 May 2017.
- Adams, Sheena (23 September 2006). "Farmer armies in the killing fields". IOL News. Retrieved 27 October 2006.
- Ntsaluba, Gcina (29 April 2008). "Anti-Farmer hate speech slated". News24. Retrieved 24 May 2011.
- Manby, Bronwen (2002). "A Failure of Rural Protection". Transformation (49): 92–94. doi:10.1353/trn.2003.0004.
- "In-depth: Civilian Protection in Armed Conflict". IRIN. 3 March 2003. Archived from the original on 11 November 2009. Retrieved 15 August 2018.
- Chitja, Twala; Oelofse, Marietjie (2013). "Rural Safety and the Disbandment of the Commando Units in South Africa: A Challenge to Rural Communities and the African National Congress (ANC)?" (PDF). Stud Tribes Tribals. 11 (1): 25–33. Retrieved 7 December 2013.
- "Farmland crop of white crosses". The Star. 4 June 2012. Archived from the original on 8 September 2016. Retrieved 18 August 2016.
- "Graham Power: How plea to stop farm murders sparked SA's million-plus prayer meeting". BizNews.com. 24 April 2017. Retrieved 26 April 2017.
- Adriaanse, Dominic (31 October 2017). "#BlackMonday: City swamped by more protesters than planned". IOL News. Retrieved 31 October 2017.
- Lindeque, Mia (31 October 2017). "Police Ministry criticises #BlackMonday protests". Eye Witness News. Retrieved 31 October 2017.
- Magwedze, Hitekani (31 October 2017). "ANC condemns display of old SA flags during #BlackMonday protest". Eye Witness News. Retrieved 31 October 2017.
- "#BlackMonday promoted anti-black racism - EFF". Daily Maverick. 31 October 2017. Retrieved 31 October 2017.
- Mhlangu, Mapi. "Editor's Note: Fact checking continues to be critical in media". eNCA. Retrieved 15 January 2018.
- "Black Monday hubris: Is this why farmers were so brutally murdered?". PoliticsWeb. 6 November 2017. Retrieved 7 November 2017.
- Gedye, Lloyd (23 March 2018). "White genocide: How the big lie spread to the US and beyond". Mail & Guardian. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Snyman, Adriaan (1993). Stem van 'n Profeet. Hugenote Publikasies. ISBN 095837791X.
- WW3: Germans, Boers, Race War, Suidlanders, Simon Roche, Siener Van Rensburg & Adriaan Synman (podcast). 19 July 2017 – via Internet Archive.
- de Wet, Phillip (13 December 2013). "Mandela's death - apocalypse any second now, surely". Mail & Guardian. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Bornman, Jan (23 March 2018). "SA conservative group takes credit for increased 'white genocide' awareness". News24. Retrieved 20 April 2018.
- "AfriForum se Kriel en Roets na VSA vir bewusmaking oor plaasmoorde en onteiening" [Afriforum's Kriel and Roets travel to USA to raise awareness of farm murders and expropriation]. Forum Nuus. 1 May 2018. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
After an Australian journalist visiting South Africa was taken on a tour of South Africa by Afriforum, literally dozens of articles appeared in the Australian media about farm murders and the ANC government's misjudgment on property rights
- "AfriForum's U.S. Adventure: Playing With Fire, Just Like In Oz". Huffington Post South Africa. 4 May 2018. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Chung, Frank (21 May 2017). "South Africans trapped 'like frogs in boiling water' as racial violence escalates". News.com.au. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- "Killed because you're white". The Australian. 17 March 2018.
- Fallon, Amy (17 March 2018). "White South African farmers dig in against deadly 'persecution'". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Karp, Paul (14 March 2018). "Australia considers fast-track visas for white South African farmers". The Guardian. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Gribbin, Caitlyn; Sara, Sally (15 March 2018). "Peter Dutton wants Australia to help White South African farmers who he says are facing violence, land seizures". ABC News. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- McCulloch, Daniel (14 March 2018). "Peter Dutton looks to help 'persecuted' white South African farmers". The Canberra Times. Archived from the original on 15 March 2018.
- Norman, Jane (16 March 2018). "Peter Dutton's white South African farmers resettlement gaining momentum". ABC News. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Bornman, Jan (20 March 2018). "SA would need to deteriorate 'markedly' for white farmers to get refugee status – Australian senator". News24. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Barbour, Lucy (22 March 2018). "Nationals MP fears food shortages in South Africa if white farmers migrate". ABC News. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Mtyala, Quinton (15 March 2018). "Dirco demands #PeterDutton retract 'persecuted' white farmer comments". IOL News. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Mabaya, Ndivhuwo (16 March 2018). "White farmers: Peter Dutton must retract remarks". Politicsweb. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Killalea, Debra (16 March 2018). "South Africa: Peter Dutton's 'white farmer' comments anger Pretoria". News.com.au. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- "South African farmers coalition, MPs raise concerns". The Australian. Retrieved 20 April 2018.
- Fabricius, Peter (29 March 2018). "Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull retracts Peter Dutton's offer to help white South African farmers". Daily Maverick. Retrieved 20 April 2018.
- Fabricius, Peter (2 April 2018). "Australia: Sisulu welcomes Canberra's retraction of 'persecuted' white farmers remark". Daily Maverick. Retrieved 20 April 2018.
- "Minister Sisulu welcomes Australian leaders' retraction of the comments made by their Home Affairs Minister". Department of International Relations and Cooperation. 2 April 2018. Retrieved 20 April 2018.
- "Dutton considering farmers as refugees". Special Broadcasting Service. 3 April 2018. Retrieved 20 April 2018.
- Knaus, Christopher; Davidson, Helen (13 April 2018). "Peter Dutton's department blocked white South African farmer's asylum bid". The Guardian. Retrieved 20 August 2018.
- Ellyatt, Holly (2018-08-23). "Trump hypes fringe talking point about South African government 'seizing land from white farmers'". CNBC. Retrieved 2018-08-27.
- "Trump Cites False Claims of Widespread Attacks on White Farmers in South Africa". Retrieved 2018-08-27.
- "SA rejects Trump tweet on farmer killings". BBC News. 2018-08-23. Retrieved 2018-08-27.
- Steinhauser, Gabriele (2018-08-23). "Trump Tweet on South African Land Overhaul Draws Government's Ire". Wall Street Journal. ISSN 0099-9660. Retrieved 2018-08-27.
- "South Africa hits back at Trump over land seizure tweet". Retrieved 2018-08-27.
- "Fox's Carlson stunned by reaction to stories on South Africa". AP News. Retrieved 2018-08-27.
- "Trump tweets incorrect on S.A. land seizures, farmers". @politifact. Retrieved 2018-08-27.
- "AP FACT CHECK: Trump's claim on South African farms off mark". Washington Post. Retrieved 2018-08-27.
- Donald Trump [@realDonaldTrump] (August 22, 2018). "I have asked Secretary of State @SecPompeo to closely study the South Africa land and farm seizures and expropriations and the large scale killing of farmers. "South African Government is now seizing land from white farmers." @TuckerCarlson @FoxNews" (Tweet) – via Twitter.
- James Masters, David McKenzie and Brent Swails (August 23, 2018). "South Africa hits back at 'unfortunate' Trump tweet on land reform". CNN. Retrieved August 25, 2018.
- Burke, Jason; Smith, David (2018-08-23). "Donald Trump's land seizures tweet sparks anger in South Africa". the Guardian. Retrieved 2018-08-27.