In particle physics, proton decay is a hypothetical form of particle decay in which the proton decays into lighter subatomic particles, such as a neutral pion and a positron. The proton decay hypothesis was first formulated by Andrei Sakharov in 1967. There is currently no experimental evidence that proton decay occurs.
According to the Standard Model, protons, a type of baryon, are stable because baryon number (quark number) is conserved (under normal circumstances; see chiral anomaly for exception). Therefore, protons will not decay into other particles on their own, because they are the lightest (and therefore least energetic) baryon. Positron emission – a form of radioactive decay which sees a proton become a neutron – is not proton decay, since the proton interacts with other particles within the atom.
Some beyond-the-Standard Model grand unified theories (GUTs) explicitly break the baryon number symmetry, allowing protons to decay via the Higgs particle, magnetic monopoles, or new X bosons with a half-life of 1031 to 1036 years. To date, all attempts to observe new phenomena predicted by GUTs (like proton decay or the existence of magnetic monopoles) have failed.
Quantum gravity (via virtual black holes and Hawking radiation) may also provide a venue of proton decay at magnitudes or lifetimes well beyond the GUT scale decay range above, as well as extra dimensions in supersymmetry.
There are other theoretical methods of baryon violation other than proton decay including interactions with changes of baryon and/or lepton number other than 1 (as required in proton decay). These included B and/or L violations of 2, 3, or other numbers, or B − L violation. Such examples include neutron oscillations and the electroweak sphaleron anomaly at high energies and temperatures that can result between the collision of protons into antileptons or vice versa (a key factor in leptogenesis and non-GUT baryogenesis).
|Unsolved problem in physics:|
(more unsolved problems in physics)
One of the outstanding problems in modern physics is the predominance of matter over antimatter in the universe. The universe, as a whole, seems to have a nonzero positive baryon number density – that is, matter exists. Since it is assumed in cosmology that the particles we see were created using the same physics we measure today, it would normally be expected that the overall baryon number should be zero, as matter and antimatter should have been created in equal amounts. This has led to a number of proposed mechanisms for symmetry breaking that favour the creation of normal matter (as opposed to antimatter) under certain conditions. This imbalance would have been exceptionally small, on the order of 1 in every 000000000 (1010) particles a small fraction of a second after the Big Bang, but after most of the matter and antimatter annihilated, what was left over was all the baryonic matter in the current universe, along with a much greater number of 10bosons. Experiments reported in 2010 at Fermilab, however, seem to show that this imbalance is much greater than previously assumed. In an experiment involving a series of particle collisions, the amount of generated matter was approximately 1% larger than the amount of generated antimatter. The reason for this discrepancy is yet unknown.
Most grand unified theories explicitly break the baryon number symmetry, which would account for this discrepancy, typically invoking reactions mediated by very massive X bosons (
) or massive Higgs bosons (
). The rate at which these events occur is governed largely by the mass of the intermediate
particles, so by assuming these reactions are responsible for the majority of the baryon number seen today, a maximum mass can be calculated above which the rate would be too slow to explain the presence of matter today. These estimates predict that a large volume of material will occasionally exhibit a spontaneous proton decay.
Proton decay is one of the key predictions of the various grand unified theories (GUTs) proposed in the 1970s, another major one being the existence of magnetic monopoles. Both concepts have been the focus of major experimental physics efforts since the early 1980s. To date, all attempts to observe these events have failed; however, these experiments have been able to establish lower bounds on the half-life of the proton. Currently the most precise results come from the Super-Kamiokande water Cherenkov radiation detector in Japan: a 2015 analysis placed a lower bound on the proton's half-life of ×1034 years via positron decay, 1.67 and similarly, a 2012 analysis gave a lower bound to the proton's half-life of ×1034 years via 1.08antimuon decay, close to a supersymmetry (SUSY) prediction of 1034–1036 years. An upgraded version, Hyper-Kamiokande, probably will have sensitivity 5–10 times better than Super-Kamiokande.
Despite the lack of observational evidence for proton decay, some grand unification theories, such as the SU(5) Georgi–Glashow model and SO(10), along with their supersymmetric variants, require it. According to such theories, the proton has a half-life of about 1031 to 1036 years and decays into a positron and a neutral pion that itself immediately decays into 2 gamma ray photons:
Additional decay modes are available (e.g.:
), both directly and when catalyzed via interaction with GUT-predicted magnetic monopoles. Though this process has not been observed experimentally, it is within the realm of experimental testability for future planned very large-scale detectors on the megaton scale. Such detectors include the Hyper-Kamiokande.
Early grand unification theories (GUTs) such as the Georgi–Glashow model, which were the first consistent theories to suggest proton decay, postulated that the proton's half-life would be at least 1031 years. As further experiments and calculations were performed in the 1990s, it became clear that the proton half-life could not lie below 1032 years. Many books from that period refer to this figure for the possible decay time for baryonic matter. More recent findings have pushed the minimum proton half-life to at least 1034-1035 years, ruling out the simpler GUTs (including minimal SU(5)/Georgi–Glashow) and most non-SUSY models. The maximum upper limit on proton lifetime (if unstable), is calculated at 6 × 1039 years, a bound applicable to SUSY models, with a maximum for (minimal) non-SUSY GUTs at 1.4 × 1036 years.
Although the phenomenon is referred to as "proton decay", the effect would also be seen in neutrons bound inside atomic nuclei. Free neutrons—those not inside an atomic nucleus—are already known to decay into protons (and an electron and an antineutrino) in a process called beta decay. Free neutrons have a half-life of about 10 minutes (±0.8 s) 610.2 due to the weak interaction. Neutrons bound inside a nucleus have an immensely longer half-life—apparently as great as that of the proton.
Projected proton lifetimes
|Theory class||Proton lifetime (years)|
|Minimal SU(5) (Georgi–Glashow)||1030...1031|
|Minimal SUSY SU(5)||1028...1032|
|Minimal (Basic) SO(10) – Non SUSY||< ~1035 (maximum range)|
|SUSY SO(10) MSSM G(224)||2·1034|
|Flipped SU(5) (MSSM)||1035...1036|
|SUSY SU(5) – 5 dimensions||1034...1035|
Dimension-6 proton decay operators
The dimension-6 proton decay operators are , , and where is the cutoff scale for the Standard Model. All of these operators violate both baryon number (B) and lepton number (L) conservation but not the combination B − L.
In GUT models, the exchange of an X or Y boson with the mass ΛGUT can lead to the last two operators suppressed by . The exchange of a triplet Higgs with mass can lead to all of the operators suppressed by . See doublet–triplet splitting problem.
Dimension-5 proton decay operators
In supersymmetric extensions (such as the MSSM), we can also have dimension-5 operators involving two fermions and two sfermions caused by the exchange of a tripletino of mass M. The sfermions will then exchange a gaugino or Higgsino or gravitino leaving two fermions. The overall Feynman diagram has a loop (and other complications due to strong interaction physics). This decay rate is suppressed by where MSUSY is the mass scale of the superpartners.
Dimension-4 proton decay operators
In the absence of matter parity, supersymmetric extensions of the Standard Model can give rise to the last operator suppressed by the inverse square of sdown quark mass. This is due to the dimension-4 operators
The proton decay rate is only suppressed by which is far too fast unless the couplings are very small.
Proton decay in media
When Woody Allen in his 1980 film Stardust Memories launches a depressive soliloquy with the quote, "Did anybody read on the front page of The Times that matter is decaying?", this was almost certainly a reference to the GUTs models of the 1970s, given the film's period, their importance at the time and the many contemporary layperson articles in general media about some of the model's most striking consequences, particularly its mechanism for proton decay.
In the Law & Order episode "Big Bang", a scientist's pursuit of evidence that proton decay exists leads to the murder central to the episode.
In the Jerry Spinelli novel Smiles to Go, the notion of proton decay is a key source of anxiety for the book's protagonist.
- Radioactive decays by Protons. Myth or reality?, Ishfaq Ahmad, The Nucleus, 1969. pp 69–70
- "Bloch Wave Function for the Periodic Sphaleron Potential and Unsuppressed Baryon and Lepton Number Violating Processes", S.H. Henry Tyne & Sam S.C. Wong. (2015). Phys. Rev. D, 92(4), 045005 (2015-08-05). DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevD.92.045005
V.M. Abazov; et al. (2010). "Evidence for an anomalous like-sign dimuon charge asymmetry". Physical Review D. 82 (3). arXiv:1005.2757
. Bibcode:2010PhRvD..82c2001A. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.82.032001.
- Bajc, Borut; Hisano, Junji; Kuwahara, Takumi; Omura, Yuji (2016). "Threshold corrections to dimension-six proton decay operators in non-minimal SUSY SU(5) GUTs". Nuclear Physics B. 910: 1. arXiv:1603.03568
. Bibcode:2016NuPhB.910....1B. doi:10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2016.06.017.
H. Nishino; Super-K Collaboration (2012). "Search for Proton Decay via
in a Large Water Cherenkov Detector". Physical Review Letters. 102 (14): 141801. arXiv:0903.0676
. Bibcode:2009PhRvL.102n1801N. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.102.141801. PMID 19392425.
- "Proton lifetime is longer than 1034 years". www-sk.icrr.u-tokyo.ac.jp. 25 November 2009.
- B. V. Sreekantan (1984). "Searches for Proton Decay and Superheavy Magnetic Monopoles" (PDF). Journal of Astrophysics and Astronomy. 5 (3): 251–271. Bibcode:1984JApA....5..251S. doi:10.1007/BF02714542.
- Nath, Pran; Fileviez Pérez, Pavel (2007). "Proton stability in grand unified theories, in strings and in branes". Physics Reports. 441 (5–6): 191. arXiv:hep-ph/0601023
. Bibcode:2007PhR...441..191N. doi:10.1016/j.physrep.2007.02.010.
- Nath and Perez, 2007, part 5.6
K.A. Olive; et al. (2014). "Review of Particle Physics – N Baryons" (PDF). Chinese Physics C. 38 (9): 090001. arXiv:astro-ph/0601168
. Bibcode:2006JPhG...33....1Y. doi:10.1088/1674-1137/38/9/090001.
- "Grand Unified Theories and Proton Decay", Ed Kearns, Boston University, 2009, page 15. http://physics.bu.edu/NEPPSR/TALKS-2009/Kearns_GUTs_ProtonDecay.pdf
- C. Amsler; Particle Data Group (2008). "Review of Particle Physics – N Baryons" (PDF). Physics Letters B. 667: 1–6. Bibcode:2008PhLB..667....1A. doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2008.07.018.
- K. Hagiwara; Particle Data Group (2002). "Review of Particle Physics – N Baryons" (PDF). Physical Review D. 66: 010001. Bibcode:2002PhRvD..66a0001H. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.66.010001.
- F. Adams; G. Laughlin. The Five Ages of the Universe : Inside the Physics of Eternity. ISBN 978-0-684-86576-8.
- L.M. Krauss. Atom : An Odyssey from the Big Bang to Life on Earth. ISBN 0-316-49946-3.
- D.-D. Wu; T.-Z. Li (1985). "Proton decay, annihilation or fusion?". Zeitschrift für Physik C. 27 (2): 321–323. Bibcode:1985ZPhyC..27..321W. doi:10.1007/BF01556623.
- P. Nath; P. Fileviez Perez (2007). "Proton stability in grand unified theories, in strings and in branes". Physics Reports. 441 (5–6): 191–317. arXiv:hep-ph/0601023
. Bibcode:2007PhR...441..191N. doi:10.1016/j.physrep.2007.02.010.