According to Jarrod Tanny, most historians argue that the earlier incidents were a result of "frictions unleashed by modernization" rather than antisemitism. The 1905 pogrom was markedly larger in scale and antisemitism played a central role.
Odessa is a port city on the Black Sea and its multi-ethnic population included Greek, Jewish, Russian, Ukrainian, and other communities.
The 1821 pogrom, perpetrated by ethnic Greeks rather than Russians, is named in some sources as the first in the modern period in Russia:
In Odessa, Greeks and Jews were two rival ethnic and economic communities, living side by side. The first Odessa pogrom, in 1821, was linked to the outbreak of the Greek War for Independence, during which the Jews were accused of sympathizing with the Ottoman authorities and of aiding the Turks in killing the Greek Patriarch of Constantinople, Gregory V, dragging his dead body through the streets and finally throwing it into the Bosphorus.
According to the Jewish Encyclopedia (1906 ed.),
The community did not escape the horrors of the pogrom. Indeed, the very first pogrom in Russia occurred in Odessa in the year 1859. This was in reality not a Russian but a Greek pogrom; for the leaders and almost all of the participants were Greek sailors from ships in the harbor, and local Greeks who joined them. The pogrom occurred on a Christian Easter; and the local press, in no wise unfriendly to the Jews, attempted to transform it into an accidental fight, the Greek colony at that time being dominant in the administration as well as in the commerce of Odessa. Further pogroms occurred in 1871, 1881, and 1886."
However, after 1871, the pogroms in Odessa took a form more typical of the rest of the Russian empire: "Although the pogrom of 1871 was occasioned in part by a rumor that Jews had vandalized the Greek community's church, many non-Greeks participated to it. Russian resentment and hostility toward Jews came to the fore in the pogrom of 1871 as Russians joined Greeks in attacks on Jews. Thereafter, Russians filled the ranks of pogromist mobs in 1881, 1900, and 1905." In the 1881 and 1905 pogroms, many Greek houses were also destroyed.
The 1871 pogrom is seen as something of a turning point in Russian Jewish history: "The Odessa pogrom led some Jewish publicists, exemplified by the writer Peretz Smolenskin, to question belief in the possibility of Jewish integration into Christian society, and to call for a greater awareness of Jewish national identity."
The Bolshevik Piatnitsky who was in Odessa at the time recalls what happened: "There I saw the following scene: a gang of young men, between 25 and 20 years old, among whom there were plain-clothes policemen and members of the Okhrana, were rounding up anyone who looked like a Jew—men, women and children—stripping them naked and beating them mercilessly... We immediately organised a group of revolutionaries armed with revolvers... we ran up to them and fired at them. They ran away. But suddenly between us and the pogromists there appeared a solid wall of soldiers, armed to the teeth and facing us. We retreated. The soldiers went away, and the pogromists came out again. This happened a few times. It became clear to us that the pogromists were acting together with the military."
The 1905 Pogrom of Odessa was the worst anti-Jewish pogrom in Odessa's history. Between October 18 and 22, 1905, ethnic Russians, Ukrainians, and Greeks killed over 400 Jews and damaged or destroyed over 1600 Jewish properties.
Background of Jews in Odessa
The city of Odessa, founded in the late 18th century, encouraged foreign immigration, especially for the purpose of promoting economic growth. For this reason, Jews were far more welcome in Odessa than in many other parts of the Pale of Settlement. Nonetheless, Jews of Odessa were not viewed as equal to non-Jewish residents and were familiar with anti-Semitism. A number of serious anti-Jewish pogroms occurred during the 19th century in Odessa, and rumors of a pogrom appeared each year around Eastertime. Jewish and Russian youths also often got into violent fights with each other.
The combination of economic downturn, Jewish backing of Japan in the war against Russia, Jewish opposition to the October Manifesto, and the June 1905 massacre all contributed to great tension between Gentiles and the Jewish community in Odessa in 1905.
Anti-Semitism among Greeks:
Growing anti-Semitism as a result of the changing place of Jews in Odessa's economy created an environment conducive to a pogrom. When the Crimean War disrupted trade routes, many Greek commercial firms shifted their business out of Odessa due to bankruptcy or a willingness to seek more profitable trading locations. To fill the resulting vacuum in grain trade, Jewish merchants expanded business and began to acquire greater profits. Many factors contributed to the spread of anti-Semitism among Greeks in Odessa including: the success of many Jewish traders, their preferential hiring of Jewish workers, and rumors of hostile actions by Jews toward Greeks.
Anti-Semitism among Russians:
Many Russians blamed the Jews for their troubles, such as limited employment opportunities and lower wages. They cited dramatic Jewish population growth in Odessa, from 14% (14,000 of 100,000) in 1858 to 35% (140,000 of 400,000) in 1897. These numbers contributed to suspicion that Jews possessed great wealth, power, and influence in Odessa. Although by the end of the 19th century Jews held high positions in manufacturing, the majority of wealth in Odessa belonged to non-Jews. Jews certainly did not dominate the economy of Odessa, nor did they control Odessa politically. Unlike other ethnic and religious groups, wealthy Jews could not transform wealth into political power. Out of 3449 total staff, only 71 Jews worked for the imperial government. After an 1892 civic reform, Jews could no longer elect representatives to city councils; instead, a special office for municipal affairs appointed six Jews to the sixty-person Odessa city council. Given that 35% of Odessa's population in 1897 consisted of Jews, the 10% Jewish city council was hardly representative.
A significant economic downturn in Odessa at the turn of the 20th century played a major part in the October Pogrom. Restricted trading, reduced industrial production, and the Russo-Japanese War led to high unemployment in Odessa. Many despised Jews for lay-offs during the economic recession. Hatred for Jews heightened when a number of Jews did not support the war with Japan. Patriotic Russians called Jews unpatriotic and disloyal.
Fear of a pogrom in April 1905 prompted the National Committee of Jewish Self-Defense to urge Jews to arm themselves and protect their property. Non-Jews were threatened with armed retaliation if a pogrom occurred. Although a pogrom did not take place until October, fear of one re-emerged in June when Jews were declared culpable for instigating shootings as well as fires at the port. On June 13, 1905, Cossacks shot several striking workers. The next day, large groups of workers stopped working and attacked police with rocks and guns. The battleship Potemkin, whose crew had mutinied on June 14, arrived in Odessa that evening. Thousands of Odessans went to the port to see the battleship and support the mutinous sailors. During the afternoon of 15 June, the unruly crowd began to raid warehouses and set fire to wooden buildings in the harbor. Chaos ensued when, in order to prevent further unrest, the military blocked off the harbor and fired into the crowd. Strikes, disorder, and the arrival of Potemkin caused the death of over 1,000 people at the Port of Odessa. A few days after the atrocious incident at the harbor, an anti-Semitic pamphlet called Odesskie dni ("Odessan Days") appeared, blaming the Jews for the tragedy. Odesskie dni demanded compensation by Jews to the non-Jews, disarmament of Jews in Odessa, and a search of all Jewish apartments in the city. Although the events of June did not immediately cause a pogrom, an anti-Semitic environment had been formed, sufficient for the October Pogrom.
On October 17, Tsar Nicholas II issued the October Manifesto, which established civil liberties for the people and promised to create an elected assembly. It was reported in Odessa on October 18, causing celebration in the streets. Jews hoped that the Manifesto would lead to greater freedom and less anti-Semitism in the Russian Empire. While many Jews and liberals in Odessa celebrated the October Manifesto, conservatives saw the document as a threat to the autocracy and the might of the Russian Empire.
The October Pogrom
Buildup to pogrom: October 14th–17th
On October 14, a number of high school students skipped classes and attempted, but failed, to join rallies taking place at the university due to police intervention. In the process of intercepting them, armed policeman injured several children. The next day, radical students and revolutionaries armed themselves and encouraged other workers to lend them support. On October 16, students and workers took to the streets and erected barricades. To try to preserve order, the police fought them and killed several students. Although a public funeral had been planned for the students, the Odessa city governor, D. M. Neidhart, had the bodies buried secretly to limit rallying around the deaths. On October 17, the police and military continued to monitor the streets, though no major confrontations occurred. About 4000 workers, including many Jews, went on strike.
Crisis: October 18th
On October 18, Jews and liberals cheered over the news of the October Manifesto. Although demonstrations began peacefully, they quickly turned violent. Those chanting anti-regime propaganda caused trouble when they took out red flags and anti-imperial propaganda. As violence increased between supporters and opponents of the October Manifesto, members of the latter group began to take out their anger on Odessa's Jews, identifying them as the root of Russia's troubles. When a group of Jews asked a few Russian workers to show respect to a red flag, a fight broke out on the streets and soon turned into an anti-Jewish riot.
Pogrom: October 19th–21st
The bulk of the October Pogrom took place on October 19-21 and was worst on October 20. Violence spread all over Odessa, from the city center, to the suburbs, and to nearby villages. The rioters demonstrated excellent organization throughout sections of Odessa, coordinating their numbers based on the size of the neighborhood under attack. Rather than working to protect Jews and end the pogrom, many policemen and soldiers wearing civilian clothes watched or participated in the massacre. Though they suffered many casualties and were eventually vanquished, Jewish self-defense forces successfully defended some houses as well as streets and even neighborhoods.
On October 21, after much of the pogrom was over, the city governor of Odessa, D. M. Neidhart, and the commander of the Odessa military garrison, A. V. Kaul'bars, appeared in the streets, and told the rioters to get off the streets and go home. Neidhart and Kaul'bars' inaction up to this point became the subject of debate and led to Neidhart's subsequent resignation from office.
Aftermath and Jewish response
Various reports estimate the number of Jews killed in the October Pogrom from 302 to 1,000. Other relevant statistics from the pogrom include approximately 5,000 injured Jews, 3.75 million rubles in property damage, 1,400 ruined business, and 3,000 families forced into poverty. The Odessa Jewish Central Committee to Aid the Victims of the Pogroms of 1905 collected 672,833 rubles from Jews in Odessa and abroad to aid those hurt by the pogrom. In total, the committee assisted 2,499 families affected by the October Pogrom.
- Robert Weinberg, "The Pogrom of 1905 in Odessa: A Case Study" in Pogroms: Anti-Jewish Violence in Modern Russian History, John D. Klier and Shlomo Lambroza, eds. (Cambridge,1992): 248-89; Robert Weinberg "Workers, Pogroms, and the 1905 Revolution in Odessa" The Russian Review, vol. 46, 1987, pp. 53–75
- Tanny, Jarrod (2011). City of Rogues and Schnorrers: Russia's Jews and the Myth of Old Odessa.
Such violent incidents, as most historians argue today, were largely the product of frictions unleashed by modernization, not a resurgence of medieval anti-Semitism and Judeophobia.
- Ariel Parkansky "Anti-Semitism and Pogroms" KehilaLinks
- "Odessa", Jewish Encyclopedia, 1906 ed.
- The Revolution of 1905 in Odessa: Blood on the Steps, Robert Weinberg, p. 16
- Ariel Parkansky "Anti-Semitism and Pogroms" KehilaLinks
- Port Jews: Jewish Communities in Cosmopolitan Maritime Trading Centres, 1550, David Cesarani, p. 168
- John Klier "Pogroms" YIVO Encyclopedia of Jews in Eastern Europe
- Nicholas II. Life and Death by Edward Radzinsky (Russian ed., 1997) p.89. According to Edward Radzinsky, Sergei Witte, who was appointed Chairman of the Russian Council of Ministers in 1905, remarked in his Memoirs that he found that some proclamations inciting pogroms were printed and distributed by Police.
- Alan Woods. Bolshevism: The Road to Revolution Archived 2007-09-30 at the Wayback Machine.. Part Two: The First Russian Revolution
- Antisemitism: A Historical Encyclopedia of Prejudice and Persection, Volume 2, L–Z , ed. Richard S. Levy (Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, 2005), s.v. "Odessa Pogroms."
- Robert Weinberg, "The Pogrom of 1905 in Odessa," in Pogroms: Anti-Jewish Violence in Modern Russian History, ed. John D. Klier and Shlomo Lambroza. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992), 250-251.
- Weinberg, "The Pogrom of 1905 in Odessa," 251.
- Robert Weinberg, "Anti-Jewish Violence and Revolution in Late Imperial Russia," in Riots and Pogroms, ed. Paul Brass. (New York: New York University Press, 1996), 58–59.
- Weinberg, "The Pogrom of 1905 in Odessa," 254.
- Herlihy, Patricia. "A Decade of Disturbance, 1904-1914", in Odessa: A History 1794-1914. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press (1986) pg. 304.
- Weinberg, The Pogrom of 1905 in Odessa, pg. 256.
- Weinberg, Robert. "Breathing Spell and Renewed Confrontation", in The Revolution of 1905 In Odessa: Blood On The Steps. Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University Press, 1993. pg. 161.
- Herlihy, "A Decade of Disturbance, 1904-1914," 305.
- Weinberg, "The Pogrom of 1905 in Odessa," 260.
- Herlihy, "A Decade of Disturbance, 1904-1914," 306-307.
- Weinberg, "The Pogrom of 1905 in Odessa," 260.
- Weinberg, "The Pogrom of 1905 in Odessa," 260–262.
- Herlihy, pg. 306.
- Herlihy, pg. 306–307.
- Herlihy, pg. 307.
- Weinberg, Robert (1992). "The Pogrom of 1905 in Odessa: A Case Study excerpts". In John D. Klier; Shlomo Lambroza. Pogroms: Anti-Jewish Violence in Modern Russian History. pp. 248–89.
- "Pogroms, 1871-1906" Center for Online Judaic Studies COJS.org