Antisemitism in 21st-century France
|Part of a series on|
Part of Jewish history
Antisemitism in France has become heightened since the late 20th century and into the 21st century. In the early 21st century, most Jews in France, like most Muslims in France, are of North African origin. France has the largest population of Jews in the diaspora after United States—an estimated 500,000–600,000 persons. Paris has the highest population, followed by Marseilles, which has 70,000 Jews, most of North African origin.
Expressions of anti-semitism were seen to rise during the Six-Day War of 1967 and the French anti-Zionist campaign of the 1970s and 1980s. Following the electoral successes achieved by the extreme right-wing National Front and an increasing denial of the Holocaust among some persons in the 1990s, surveys showed an increase in stereotypical antisemitic beliefs among the general French population.
At the beginning of the 21st century, antisemitism in France rose sharply during the unrest of the Second Intifada in Israel and the Palestinian territories, as it did in other European nations. In addition, a significant proportion of the second-generation Muslim immigrant population in France began to identify with the Palestinian cause, with some also identifying with radical Islamism. In the early 2000s, a critical debate on the nature of antisemitism in France accompanied denunciation of it in relation to the situation in the Middle East and to Islam. Divisions developed among anti-racist groups.
Alarmed by violence and verbal attacks, some French Jews began to emigrate to Israel. By early 2014 the number of French Jews making aliyah (emigrating to Israel) surpassed the number of American Jews who were emigrating. At the same time 70 percent of French Jews reported in surveys that they were concerned about insults or harassment and 60% about physical aggression because of their ethnicity; both figures are much higher than shown in surveys of the European average.
At the turn of the 21st century, France had an estimated 500,000 to 600,000 Jews, most of them Sephardic and of North African origin. This is the second-largest population outside of Israel, and after that in the United States. A quarter of the historic Ashkenazi Jewish population in France died in the Holocaust of World War II. After the war, the French government passed laws to suppress antisemitic discrimination and actions, and to protect Jews in the country.
In the 1950s and 1960s, many Sephardic Jews emigrated to France from countries such as Algeria, Morocco, and Tunisia, which had gained independence from colonial rule through extended warfare against France. The wars for independence left both sides with considerable bitterness, and Algeria was immersed in civil war for years after gaining independence. Jews left North Africa as relations in the area became more strained during the Six-Day War of 1967 between Israel, Egypt and other Arab forces. This increased tensions across the Arab world. The rise of the Second Intifada, beginning in 2000, contributed to rising tensions with Arab Muslims and Jews feeling less welcome in North African nations. Most have now left the region.
Beginning in the late 20th century, more Arabs from North African nations began to emigrate to France for economic reasons and to escape civil wars in their home nations. Historically numerous North African Arabs had lived and worked in France since before World War II. The Muslim community built the Grand Mosque in Paris in 1929. Its Imam (Si Kaddour Benghabrit) and numerous members helped protect Jews from deportation during the Holocaust.
In the mid-1990s historians renewed a critical study of National Socialism, collaboration, and the responsibility of the Vichy Regime for deportation of Jews during the Holocaust. They contested the book Vichy France: Old Guard and New Order, 1940-1944 (1972) (published in French as La France de Vichy) by American historian Robert Paxton, who had said the Vichy Regime cooperated with the Nazi Germans.
British historian Maud S. Mandel bases her inquiry Jews and Muslims in France: A History of a Conflict (2014) on historic relations among the peoples of North Africa. She attributes the roots of Muslim antisemitism among second-generation immigrants in France to earlier inter-communal relations among the peoples in Algeria, Tunisia, and Morocco; the course of decolonization in North Africa; and events in the continuing Arab–Israeli conflict. Sociologists such as Nonna Mayer, Laurent Mucchielli and others have said that anti-semitic opinions have been in decline in France since the end of the Second World War, and that other forms of racism have been more widespread than antisemitism. Members of the French Jewish community criticized this conclusion.
France has struggled to help Arab working-class youth find work, as their unemployment rate is high. In their isolated public housing communities outside Paris, anti-semitic sentiment is prevalent. In 2016 Paris has the largest population of Jews in France, followed by Marseilles, which has 70,000.
Many working-class Arabs and Sephardic Jews also settled in cities in southern France, which had long been linked by trade and culture to North Africa. In many of these communities, such as Nice and Marseilles, Arab and Jewish immigrants from North African nations have lived in mixed communities as they began to make new lives in France. Both Jews and Muslims are minorities in France. Many North African Jews worked with Arab immigrants to combat racism in France against the latter group, and support other progressive causes.
French concerns about antisemitism among second-generation Arab groups is also related to general concerns about Islamic terrorism in the country. In 2015 Paris suffered two major Islamic attacks, which were generally targeted at all French people. In addition, from the end of 2015 into early 2016, there were independent attacks against individual Jews in several cities, including three in Marseilles from October to January.
In 2017 it was reported that "A former principal at a preparatory school for teenagers...said he regularly advised Jews not to attend his institution for fear of harassment by other students" and that only a third of Jews attend public schools.
The National Consultative Commission on Human Rights (Commission nationale consultative des droits de l'homme, CNCDH) has issued annual reports on antisemitic activities as part of the French oversight of human rights. It recorded disturbing levels of antisemitic actions and threats in France between 2002–2004 (the height of the Second Intifada), and in 2009. According to CNCDH, it defined actions to be tracked as homicides, attacks and attempted attacks, arson, degradations, and violence and assault and battery. Antisemitic threats are defined as covering speech acts, threatening gestures and insults, graffiti (inscriptions), pamphlets and emails. Its data was relied on in the FRA (European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights) report of anti-semitism incidents in France from 2001–2011, which was issued in June 2012.
|Antisemitic actions and
threats recorded in France
The Criminal Affairs and Pardon Board at the Ministry of Justice (Direction des affaires criminelles et des graces, DACG) keeps records related to the number of indictments charged in the calendar year in relation to racist, antisemitic and discriminatory offenses.
|Indictments relating to offences relating to racism||Indictments relating principally to racist offences||Indictments relating exclusively to racist offences|
2000 to 2014
The 2002 Lyon car attack was part of a wave of increased attacks on Jews and Jewish targets in France in the early 21st century. Analysts related it to the Second Intifada in Israel and the Palestinian territories.
On January 21, 2006, Ilan Halimi, a young French Jewish man of Moroccan descent was kidnapped by a group called the Gang of Barbarians, led by Youssouf Fofana. Halimi was subsequently tortured over a period of three weeks, resulting in his death.
From March 11 to 19, 2012, Mohammed Merah, a French man of Algerian descent born in Toulouse, committed the Toulouse and Montauban shootings, a series of three attacks against French soldiers and civilians in Toulouse and Montauban, in the Midi-Pyrénees region. The last day he attacked a Jewish day school in Toulouse, killing a teacher and three children, and wounding a teenager. He killed a total of three French Muslim soldiers in Toulouse and Montauban, and seriously wounded a fourth. During the 30-hour police siege at his apartment on March 22, Merah wounded three police men before he was killed by a police sniper.
2015 to present
During the January 2015 Île-de-France attacks, the Porte de Vincennes siege involved a gunman taking hostages at a Kosher supermarket. In the aftermath of the attacks, the French government increased the presence of soldiers outside prominent Jewish buildings.
On 24 October 2015, 3 Jewish men outside a synagogue in Marseille were stabbed by a man shouting anti-Jewish slogans. One of the victims sustained serious abdominal wounds; he was expected to survive. The assailant was apprehended.
On 18 November 2015 a teacher in Marseille walking on the street was stabbed by three men who shouted anti-Jewish slogans; one of the men wore an ISIS T-shirt. The three men, riding two scooters, had approached the teacher and stabbed him in the arm and in the leg. They fled when a car approached.
On January 12, 2016 Benjamin Amsellem, a teacher, was attacked by a teenage boy wielding a machete outside a Jewish school in Marseille. The attacker claimed to be acting in the name of ISIS. Amsellem resisted by parrying some of the machete blows with the large, leather-bound Bible he was carrying. The attacker was a Kurdish Muslim whose family emigrated to France from Turkey. An excellent student from a stable, pious home, he is said by French authorities to have self-radicalized by spending long hours reading Islamist websites.
On August 18, 2016, a "confirmed anti-semite" shouted "allahou akbar" ("God is great," in English), as he attacked a 62-year-old Jew wearing a kippa on avenue des Vosges in Strasbourg. The attacker had previously stabbed another Jew in 2010 in Kléber square. The French Minister of the Interior, Bernard Cazeneuve, called the rabbi of Strasbourg to express his "solidarity." The attacker was said to have mental problems. The attacker was charged the following day with "attempted murder based on the victim's appearance belonging to a race or religion."
On April 4, 2017, retired kindergarten professor, Dr. Sarah Halimi, an Orthodox Jew, was murdered and subsequently thrown off her Paris balcony by Mali-born Kobili Traoré, who shouted "allahu akbar" as he beat her to death. The murder sparked a public conversation in France about the failure of the press to report on and the failure of the government to act on violent antisemitism in France.
In March 2018, an elderly woman, Mireille Knoll, was brutally murdered in her apartment in a subsidized housing project in Paris in a killing that was immediately declared and officially recognized as an act of Jew hatred.
Public opinion surveys
A number of surveys have been conducted of French people's attitudes toward Jews since the turn of the 21st century. Responses appeared to relate to events in the world, especially the rise in Arab-Israeli tensions in Israel and the Palestinian territories during the Second Intifada, which started in 2000. Anti-semitic views have also become associated with opposition to globalisation and, in some cases, to actions by the United States and Israel in the Mid-East.
According to the collection of two Anti-Defamation League (ADL) opinion surveys conducted in five European nations (which included France, The United Kingdom, Germany, Denmark, and Belgium) in June 2002, and five additional European nations in October 2002, 42% of respondents in France believed that Jews were more loyal to Israel than their own country, 42% said Jews have too much power in the business world, and 46% believed Jews talked too much about the Holocaust. Abraham H. Foxman, ADL National Director, said, "These findings are especially disturbing because they show that the old, classical form of antisemitism, which we had hoped was long gone in Europe, continues to be resilient".
In 2004, ADL conducted the same opinion survey in ten European nations, including France . The report said that 25% of the residents of the ten nations held antisemitic attitudes, down from 35% in five nations in 2002. 28% responded "probably true" to the statement, "Jews are more loyal to Israel than their own country", down from 42% in 2002. 15% responded "probably true" to the statement, "Jews don't care about anyone but their own kind", down from 20%.
In May 2005, the ADL published an opinion survey conducted in 12 European countries regarding popular attitudes toward Jews. The 2005 survey indicated that since 2004 and the survey of 10 nations, there was some decline in the acceptance of certain traditional antisemitic stereotypes. 25% responded "probably true" to the statement, "Jews have too much power in the business world", down from 33% in 2004, while 24% responded "probably true" to the statement "Jews have too much power in international financial markets," down from 29% in 2004.
Two years later, in May 2007, the ADL published another opinion survey conducted in five European nations. It found that 22% of respondents answered "probably true" to at least three of the four antisemitic stereotypes tested: Jews are more loyal to Israel than to this country, Jews have too much power in the business world, Jews have too much power in international financial markets, Jews still talk too much about what happened to them in the Holocaust. According to the survey, respondents believed that violence directed against French Jews was based more on anti-Jewish feelings than anti-Israel sentiment.
The Friedrich Ebert Stiftung (FES) organization published a report in 2011, Intolerance, Prejudice and Discrimination: A European Report. It concluded that anti-Semitic attitudes in France that same year, as a whole, were less widespread than the European average. According to a survey conducted by FES, 27.7% agreed with the statement "Jews have too much influence in France" and 25.8% agreed with the statement "Jews in general do not care about anything or anyone but their own kind" (implying disloyalty to the nation).
In 2012, the ADL conducted another opinion survey of antisemitic attitudes in 10 European countries. It reported that the overall level of antisemitism in France had increased to 24% of the population, up from to 20% in 2009. In terms of specific statements, 45% responded "probably true" related to "Jews are more loyal to Israel" than their own country, up from 38% in 2009. 35% responded "probably true" to the statement, "Jews have too much power in the business world", up from 33% in 2009. 29% responded "probably true" to the statement "Jews have too much power in international financial markets", up from 27% in 2009. Foxman, ADL National Director, has said regarding those findings:
In France, you have a volatile mix. France has seen an increase in the level of anti-Semitism. At the same time, more people today believe that violence directed against European Jews is fueled by anti-Jewish attitudes as opposed to anti-Israel sentiment. Those increases are all the more disturbing in light of the  shooting attack at the Jewish school in Toulouse.
Responses to antisemitism
The French Jewish establishment has traditionally worked with the government and various community groups on legal routes and education to combat and reduce anti-semitism. CRIF, an umbrella body of French Jewish communities, has used outreach and education to lessen tensions among various ethnic groups and to combat anti-semitism.
The authorities are prosecuting persons both for violent acts and for violating laws related to Holocaust denial and reducing anti-semitism. In several instances, the national or local governments have increased police protection around Jewish sites or Jewish neighborhoods in an effort to prevent attacks..
The level of violence in French society related to anti-semitism has been complicated by actions of the Ligue de Défense Juive (LDJ, French Jewish Defense League), which registered in 2001. With about 300 members in 2013, the LDJ was condemned by the French Jewish establishment, which threatens court action against it. Its relations have been strained with CRIF, the umbrella body of French Jewish communities.
A selection of other responses to anti-semitism follows:
- In December 2014, the Organization of Jewish Europeans (OJE) started using humor against French antisemitism. It distributed boxes of 'Antisemitox:' the first treatment against antisemitism. They contain three sweets, several detox patches, and the text of the law stating the penalties faced by those who express antisemitic views.
- In October 2013, the French Bar Association disbarred Alexis Dubruel, a lawyer from eastern France, after he filed a motion to disqualify judge Albert Levy, because of Jewish ancestry, from presiding over a custody case. In another case, a Paris court sentenced a blogger convicted of posting material inciting discrimination and violence against Jews to eight months in prison and a $670 fine. It ordered him to pay $2,000 in damages to people he targeted.
- In November 2007, teacher Vincent Reynouard, who had already been dismissed and convicted, was sentenced to one year imprisonment and a fine of 10,000 euros for denying the Holocaust.
- On 26 October 2007, Kemi Seba, founder of the banned Tribu KA, was sentenced in Paris to five months in prison, a fine of 10,000 euros, and the forfeiting of his civic rights for five years, for inciting racial hatred and denying crimes against humanity.
- On 21 March 2006, the Commission nationale consultative des droits de lhomme (CNCDH) recommended additional measures to the government to fight antisemitism.
- On 10 March 2006, a Paris court fined the comedian Dieudonné M'Bala M'Bala 5,000 euro for antisemitic comments.
- In November 2006, a Lyon court fined Bruno Gollnisch, second in command of the FN , 10,000 euro for questioning the existence of the Holocaust.
- On 15 January 2006, a French court fined Yahoo $15 million for selling Nazi memorabilia.
- In November 2005, the Foundation for Shoah Remembrance distributed copies of a DVD about the Holocaust to 28,000 high school students, teachers and libraries in the Paris area.
- On 13 June 2005, Judge Emmanuel Binoche ruled that Internet service providers must filter access to the AAARGH (Association of Veteran Fans of Stories of War and Holocausts), which disseminates Holocaust denial.
- On 10 February 2005, the French Broadcasting Authority ordered the French satellite provider Eutelsat to stop transmitting broadcasts from the Iranian satellite TV channel Sahar 1, following screening of antisemitic content.
- On 13 December 2004, the Council of State banned Hizballah’s al-Manar transmissions on the grounds that some of its programs were antisemitic.
- In July 2004, the Minister for Social Affairs asked the secretary general of the High Council for Integration, to evaluate government policy on the subject of combating antisemitism and to submit proposals.
- In June 2003, an appeals court in Lyon upheld editor Jean Plantin’s 6-month prison sentence, for publishing works doubting the scope of the Holocaust.
- In March 2003, a conference of Catholics and Jews took place in Paris to discuss antisemitism in Europe and the place of religion in the proposed EU constitution.
- In 2003, 19 people were arrested and 5 search warrants were issued against non-identified individuals, in connection with antisemitic offenses.
- On 12 April 2003, three students, one French, one Dutch and one Tunisian, were arrested for incitement to racial hatred and antisemitism.
- In August 2002, the government outlawed the rightist group Radical Unity.
- In February 2002, French Minister of Education Jack Lang set up a commission to examine Holocaust denial at the University of Lyon III.
- In 2001, the French anti-racism group, Action internationale pour la justice (AIPJ, another name for J’Accuse) sought a court injunction to block a Nazi US web portal Front 14, which groups some 400 racist websites.
- In 2000, the split in the FN resulted in reduced activity by the main anti-fascist organizations.
- In 2000, LICRA (Ligue internationale contre le racisme et l’antisémitisme) focused mainly on combating hate on the Internet and has set up branches abroad.
- Emmanuel Navon, "France, Israel, and the Jews: The End of an Era?", Israel Journal of Foreign Affairs, 2015, https://dx.doi.org/10.1080/23739770.2015.1042277
- "Le Surmoi antisémite de la Télévision Française", Times of Israel
- , US Holocaust Museum
- "Holocaust denial/legal concepts in Europe", Democratic Union
- Werner Bergmann and Juliane Wentzel (February 2003). "Manifestations of Antisemitism in the European Union" (PDF). EUMC (European Monitoring Centre on Racism and Xenophobia). Retrieved 9 March 2013.
- Smith, Craig S. (26 March 2006). "Jews in France Feel Sting as Antisemitism Surges Among Children of Immigrants". The New York Times. Retrieved 2010-05-04.
- "A Frenchman Or a Jew?" By Fernanda Eberstadt, New York Times Magazine, February 29, 2004
- Daniella Peled, "French hatred of Jews goes far beyond Muslim antisemitism, says U.K. author", Haaretz, 18 February 2014
- Wieviorka, Michel (2005). The Lure of Antisemitism - Hatred of Jews in Present-Day France. Netherlands: BRILL. ISBN 978-900416337-9.
- "Alarmed by antisemitism, French Jews consider flight", Deutsche Welt, 17 March 2014
- "Alarmed by anti-Semitism, French Jews consider flight". Deutsche Welt.
- "The Holocaust 's Arab Heroes", The Washington Post, October 8, 2006, Robert Satloff
- Mucchielli, Laurent (5 March 2009). "Le "retour de l'antisémitisme" : discours rituel au dîner annuel du CRIF" (PDF) (in French). Retrieved 28 March 2012.
- Mayer, Nonna (1 January 2004). "Nouvelle judéophobie ou vieil antisémitisme ?". Raisons politiques. 16 (4): 91. doi:10.3917/rai.016.0091.
- Waintrater, Meïr. "Le déni de l'antisémitisme" (in French). CRIF. Retrieved 28 March 2012.
- Nossiter, Adam (24 January 2016). "French Jews Fear a New Strain of ISIS-Inspired Anti-Semitism". New York Times. Retrieved 25 January 2016.
- Lipshiz, Cnaan (8 September 2017). "Principal in France says he warned Jews not to attend his school because they'd be harassed". JTA. Retrieved 8 September 2017.
- "Antisemitism: Summary Overview of the Situation in the European Union 2001–2011" (PDF). FRA (European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights. June 2012. Retrieved 22 February 2013.
- Diamond, Andrew (1 April 2002). "Weekend of anti-Semitism in France". JTA. Retrieved 8 August 2016.
- "Shooting in France in Wave of Anti-Jewish Attacks". New York Times. 1 April 2002. Retrieved 8 August 2016.
- Tale of Torture and Murder Horrifies the Whole of France, Michel Gurfinkiel, The New York Sun, February 22, 2006.
- Horn, Heather (19 March 2012). "The Jewish School Shooting and Patterns of Violence". The Atlantic. Retrieved 8 August 2016.
- Hadro, Matt (18 January 2016). "Anti-Semitism threatens France's Jewish communities". Washington Times. Catholic News Agency. Retrieved 24 August 2016.
- Brenner, Marie (8 July 2015). "The Troubling Question in the French Jewish Community: Is It Time to Leave?". Vanity Fair. Retrieved 24 August 2016.
- "As Soldiers Guard Parisian Synagogues, Jews Question Their Place and Their Safety in France". Haaretz.
- "French soldiers wounded in Nice Jewish centre attack". BBC News.
- "3 Jews stabbed in anti-Semitic attack in France". Times of Israel. 24 October 2005. Retrieved 14 December 2015.
- "Jewish teacher stabbed in French city of Marseille". BBC News. 18 November 2015. Retrieved 14 December 2015.
- "Jewish Teacher Stabbed in Marseille by ISIS Supporters". New York Times. 18 November 2015. Retrieved 14 December 2015.
- "Jewish teacher stabbed in Marseille street by trio praising Islamic State". The Guardian. 18 November 2015. Retrieved 14 December 2015.
- Hall, John (12 January 2016). "Marseille machete attack: 15-year-old suspect claims he stabbed Jewish teacher 'in the name of Isis'". The Telegraph. Retrieved 25 January 2016.
- AURÉLIEN POIVRET. "Un juif agressé par un déséquilibré". Darnières Nouvelles d'Alsace (in French). Retrieved 23 August 2016.
Il s'agit d'un déséquilibré de 44 ans, antisémite revendiqué
- Jacques Fortier. "Strasbourg : un juif blessé par un antisémite récidiviste". Le Monde (in French). Retrieved 23 August 2016.
l’agresseur semble ne rien avoir perdu de sa haine antisémite
- Michaël Bloch. "Un juif religieux attaqué au couteau à Strasbourg". Le Journal du Dimanche (in French). Retrieved 23 August 2016.
Un juif religieux d'une soixantaine d'années a été blessé après avoir été attaqué au couteau à Strasbourg par un homme qui a crié "Allahou Akbar".
- "Jewish man stabbed on street in French city of Strasbourg". BBC News. Retrieved 23 August 2016.
A police source said the victim was in distinctive Jewish dress
- "Strasbourg : l'auteur de l'agression au couteau contre un juif a été écroué". Paris Match (in French). Retrieved 23 August 2016.
le parquet de Strasbourg a annoncé samedi soir dans un communiqué avoir ouvert une information judiciaire «pour tentative de meurtre sur une victime en raison de son appartenance réelle ou supposée à une race ou à une religion»
- Weitzmann, Marc (25 March 2017). "Sarah Halimi Was Beaten to Death in Paris By a Muslim Attacker Reciting Verses From the Quran. The Press Covered it Up". Tablet Magazine. Retrieved 29 August 2017.
- McAuley, James (23 July 2017). "In France, murder of a Jewish woman ignites debate over the word 'terrorism'". Washington Post. Retrieved 29 August 2017.
- Goldman (17 July 2017). "Macron Denounces Anti-Zionism as 'Reinvented Form of Anti-Semitism'". The New York Times. Retrieved 29 August 2017.
[France President Macron] also called for an investigation into the death of Sarah Halimi, a 66-year-old woman who in April was thrown from the window of her Paris apartment
- Bremmer, Charles (28 March 2018). "Two charged with killing 85-year-old Holocaust survivor Mireille Knoll". The Times (of London). Retrieved 3 April 2018.
- "A 2002 ADL Survey of Five European Countries Finds One in Five Hold Strong Anti-Semitic Sentiments; Majority Believes Canard of Jewish Disloyalty". Anti-Defamation League. October 2002. Retrieved 12 December 2016.
- "ADL Survey Finds Some Decrease In Anti-Semitic Attitudes In Ten European Countries". ADL. Retrieved 16 March 2013.
- "Attitudes Toward Jews in Twelve European Countries" (PDF). ADL. Retrieved 16 March 2013.
- "Attitudes Toward Jews and the Middle East in Five European Countries" (PDF). ADL. Retrieved 16 March 2013.
- "Intolerance, Prejudice and Discrimination A European Report" (PDF). Friedrich Ebert Stiftung. Retrieved 16 March 2013.
- "ADL Survey In Ten European Countries Finds Anti-Semitism At Disturbingly High Levels". ADL. Retrieved 16 March 2013.
- Cnaan Lipshiz (25 June 2013). "France's soaring anti-Semitism lures Jewish Defense League vigilantes out of shadows". Jewish Telegraphic Agency. Retrieved 24 September 2016.
- "French Jewish group distributes Antisemitox - 'a pill to cure anti-Semitism'". International Business Times UK.
- "French lawyer disbarred for motion to replace Jewish judge". Jewish Telegraphic Agency.
- "FRANCE 2007". The Stephen Roth Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism. Retrieved 29 March 2013.
- "FRANCE 2006". The Stephen Roth Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism. Archived from the original on 19 November 2012. Retrieved 29 March 2013.
- "FRANCE 2005". The Stephen Roth Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism. Retrieved 29 March 2013.
- "FRANCE 2004". The Stephen Roth Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism. Retrieved 29 March 2013.
- "FRANCE 2003-4". The Stephen Roth Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism. Archived from the original on 19 November 2012. Retrieved 29 March 2013.
- "FRANCE 2002-3". The Stephen Roth Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism. Archived from the original on 19 November 2012. Retrieved 29 March 2013.
- "FRANCE 2001-2". The Stephen Roth Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism. Archived from the original on 19 November 2012. Retrieved 29 March 2013.
- "FRANCE 2000-1". The Stephen Roth Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism. Retrieved 29 March 2013.