Is this song swing?


Here is a song by Benny Carter, which I believe is originally from Duke Ellington: things aint what they used to be

What is the style of this song? Is it swing?

Mikey Spivak

Posted 2015-12-24T08:35:11.327

Reputation: 1 861



"Swing" refers to a specific, characteristic rhythm.

This song uses that rhythm, although it is not heavily emphasized.

The most significant characterization of this song, however, is that it is a blues.

If you are a musician, I can explain the swing rhythm to you in specific terms using music notation. If you are not a musician, I suppose it's just something you have to learn to recognize when you hear it.


Posted 2015-12-24T08:35:11.327



Although there is a "swing" rhythm (syncopated), there is also a recognized "swing" genre. I'm not convinced this song is better categorized as "blues" than swing (or some third categorization). It has definite blues elements, but it's fairly distant from what is most commonly characterized as blues. Given that the blues heavily influenced both jazz and rock, one can't just lump everything with blues influence into that category.

– Chris Sunami – 2015-12-28T13:53:32.293


The original of this song is by Duke Ellington, who was one of the most famous artists in the "swing" genre (big band jazz dance music with a syncopated beat), and it definitely has the distinctive swing beat. This recording is from long after the swing era, but it stays relatively faithful to the original. I think it would be fair to call it a jazzy swing song.

Chris Sunami

Posted 2015-12-24T08:35:11.327

Reputation: 12 950