When to use don't + pronoun

3

When have I to use "don't + pronoun"/"doesn't + pronoun"? I saw it a few times and I'm not sure how to use it.

An example could be:

You're going to school, don't you?

Inés Lpz

Posted 2016-01-26T19:53:31.170

Reputation: 66

6The idiomatic way to say your example is "You are going to school, aren't you?" (I expanded the contraction to make the parallel between are and aren't clear, not because anybody would say it that distinctly) – The Photon – 2016-01-26T20:24:52.377

3This is called a tag question. – Nihilist_Frost – 2016-01-26T21:23:50.700

Answers

12

In all the varieties of English that I am familiar with, a tag question on a sentence with an auxiliary (or a form of be even when it is a full verb) uses the auxiliary in the tag question, not do:

You are coming, aren't you?

He will win, won't he?

I can finish it, can't I?

He is, isn't he?

Only when there is no auxiliary, do we use a form of do:

You like it, don't you?

I have heard some English speakers (from Pakistan, I think, but I'm not sure) using isn't it as an invariable tag question. I don't know of any who use don't you/we/they and doesn't he/she even where there is an auxiliary, but I would not be terribly surprised if there were a variety of English somewhere that did do this.

Colin Fine

Posted 2016-01-26T19:53:31.170

Reputation: 47 277

1Aren't there some British varieties that use innit? pretty widely? Or am I just over-generalizing from stuff I've heard in movies & TV? – The Photon – 2016-01-26T22:51:03.733

@ThePhoton - yes, I think so. That's a version of "isn't it", but you're right that some people (particularly younger ones) use the short version always. – Colin Fine – 2016-01-26T22:52:26.650

In India, a lot of people say isn't it? irrespective of the sentence. It's actually a short version of saying isn't it right what I said?. Drugs are bad. Isn't it..? – NVZ – 2016-01-27T07:14:21.223

@NVZ: Thank you. I thought it might be general in Indian English, but I'm not sure. However, I suspect that your explanation is a rationalisation: do you have any evidence that that is what is in people's mind when they say "Isn't it"? I think it's more likely to be a translation from the way tag questions are formed in another language. – Colin Fine – 2016-01-27T12:56:58.000

Isn't it? comes naturally, although it's ungrammatical. I speak 4 Indian languages. So, yeah. – NVZ – 2016-01-27T13:11:43.023

1Innit is widely used as an invariable tag by young speakers in London and the surrounding areas. – Araucaria - Not here any more. – 2016-01-27T13:33:12.657

@NVZ: i wouldn't call it ungrammatical, just non-standard. – Colin Fine – 2016-01-29T00:19:44.447

6

Don't is a contraction of "do not". Doesn't is a contraction of "does not". Do and Does are forms of the verb to do. Which one to use just comes down to conjugation:

I do. You do. He does. She does. We do. They do.

So

You like apples, don't you?

but

He likes cake, doesn't he?

The Photon

Posted 2016-01-26T19:53:31.170

Reputation: 8 487

4

The two acceptable forms of this sentence are,

"You're (You are) going to school, aren't you?" (are you not?)

and,

"You go (You do go) to school, don't you?" (do you not?)

Mark Hubbard

Posted 2016-01-26T19:53:31.170

Reputation: 4 298

This gets to the right point. I might go so far as to note that the second sentence is equivalent to, and could be said to imply, You *do* go to school, don't you?. This stresses the relationship between are and are you not, and do and do you not – J... – 2016-01-27T12:04:59.940

@J... Good point. I've added your suggestion to my answer. – Mark Hubbard – 2016-01-27T14:21:02.317

2

  1. You can dance, can't you?
  2. You will dance, won't you?
  3. You have danced, haven't you?
  4. You are dancing, aren't you?

If you look at the sentences above you will see that they use the same auxiliary verb in the question as they do in the main sentence. So in the first sentence we see can and can't; in the second we see will and won't; in the third we see have and haven't; in the last wee see are and aren't. Notice that we can't use the main verb dance in the tag. We have to use an auxiliary verb.

Now look at the sentence below. Which auxiliary can you use here:

  1. You dance, ___ you?

In sentence (5) we have a problem because there is no auxiliary verb in the main sentence. When we don't have an auxiliary verb in the main sentence we have to use a dummy auxiliary. The dummy auxiliary in English is the verb DO. When we don't have an auxiliary but we need one, we always use DO. It is like a spare tyre that we keep in the back of the car:

  1. You dance, don't you?

Araucaria - Not here any more.

Posted 2016-01-26T19:53:31.170

Reputation: 25 536

1

Don't you can also appear in negative imperatives:

Don't you open that door!
Don't you touch that stove!

Normally, imperatives in English don't require any subject (addressee) pronoun. The "you" is acting as an intensifier in these sentences. Whoever is giving orders is angry, or will tolerate no disobedience. It is similar to the effect of placing a swearword in the same position:

Don't [bleep]ing open that door!

or appending the addressee's full name:

Don't open that door, Jane Windslor Wexler!

zwol

Posted 2016-01-26T19:53:31.170

Reputation: 1 205

How is this related to the question that was asked? – The Photon – 2016-01-27T05:09:24.000

@ThePhoton It's talking about "don't + [pronoun]", which is exactly the question that was asked. It explains one possible role of the pronoun in that formula, then shows non-pronouns filling the same role, to provide context for it. – Monty Harder – 2016-01-27T16:39:23.827

1

The tag question is opposite to the answer you want to suggest. So if you believe that someone goes to school and you want them to confirm it, you might say:

You go to school, don't you?

but if you think (or suspect) they don't go to school and you want them to confirm that, you could say:

You don't go to school, do you?

bdsl

Posted 2016-01-26T19:53:31.170

Reputation: 295