Using "no" to emphasize a negative statement

7

We say something like

He is no ordinary human being.

This phrasing gives the negative more emphasis than usually given by negation device "not"

He is not an ordinary human being.

It is this added emphasis that I am trying to induce in the following sentence, but I have some doubts as to the usage of "no" after the verb "makes"

Her mastery of French makes her no typical member of the laity.

May I have some feedback on the sentence, please?

Thank you.

PS: And if the sentence is Ok, would the following sound better:

Her mastery of French makes of her no typical member of the laity.

asef

Posted 2015-11-03T04:26:23.827

Reputation: 867

Absolutely okay to me! Just I'd use *'mastery on'*... – Maulik V – 2015-11-03T04:27:21.937

Never mind! Go on. But I know that students must achieve mastery on each test before going on to the next topic or unit

– Maulik V – 2015-11-03T04:41:19.467

@MaulikV *of* - 6. with (something specified) as object, goal, etc." ⇒ a reader of books"

– user3169 – 2015-11-03T04:48:00.110

@user3169 wait, this forms a very good question for me! Putting! – Maulik V – 2015-11-03T04:48:34.100

Her mastery of French makes her no typical member of the laity. The of isn't required as the sentence stands by itself and conveys the meaning intended to be conveyed. – Mamta D – 2015-11-03T06:40:24.427

If you keep the "of", the sentence means, "Due to her recent mastery of French, she has become an atypical member of the laity." – MackTuesday – 2015-11-03T19:21:13.013

Answers

1

I think there's nothing wrong grammatically with the following sentence:

Her mastery of French makes her no typical member of the laity.

On the other hand, the other sentence with the use of the phrasal verb "make of" doesn't sound correct in the sentence as someone makes something/someone of, not something makes someone/something of. You use the phrasal verb to express your opinion about or how you understand someone/something.

Khan

Posted 2015-11-03T04:26:23.827

Reputation: 26 261

0

As a native US English speaker, I think the intended meaning (emphasizing the negative) comes across better if you say

Her mastery of French makes her no ordinary member of the laity.

Chad

Posted 2015-11-03T04:26:23.827

Reputation: 1 760