What is the difference between "do you know where" and "where is"?

5

I cannot understand the difference between these two sentences about the communication between two people.

1) Do you know where my son is?

2) Where is my son?

What is the difference?

Mohammad

Posted 2015-01-23T12:33:26.427

Reputation: 329

3What firstly comes to mind is that "do you know?" is a yes or no question, but the answer to "where?" is a location. – M.A.R. – 2015-01-23T12:37:19.457

1yes that's right. I don't think before ask this question – Mohammad – 2015-01-23T12:47:49.817

@MARamezani You can write an answer :) – Man_From_India – 2015-01-23T12:52:27.207

Answers

7

Where is my son?

This question expects that you (the person I'm asking) know the answer. It's a little more complicated than that, though:

  • You might not know, but I am implying that you should know.
  • You might not know, but I might be a panicked parent who (irrationally) demands answers from you anyway.
  • I might be asking a whole group of people. Many of them won't know, but I'm assuming or hoping that someone will.

Do you know where my son is?

This leaves open the possibility that the answer is "no, I don't know". However, if you do know, it is still expected that you will tell me! If I ask this and you just answer "yes", I will think you are being deliberately troublesome.

In other words, this is an indirect way of asking the same thing. Indirect questions are generally more polite in English. That does not mean that "Where is my son?" is rude; it's just not quite as polite.


EDIT: As supercat's comment below so rightly points out, this question of politeness depends a lot on the context. If you should know where my son is (e.g. I've come to pick him up from your house), I would say to you, "Where is my son?" (Okay, I'd probably use his name, but that's beside the point.)

If, instead, I said, "Do you know where my son is?", you would have good reason to think that I was being sarcastic: I am implying that you are negligent, and so you might possibly answer "no" to my question!

Tim Pederick

Posted 2015-01-23T12:33:26.427

Reputation: 6 267

1I'd say that "where is my son" would actually be more polite than "do you know" in cases if asking someone whose failure to know instantly would constitute dereliction of duty; "do you know" is more polite in cases where the answer could plausibly be "no", but not when it shouldn't. – supercat – 2015-01-23T18:24:19.470

@supercat: Good point. A very good point, in fact; I'll edit that in. – Tim Pederick – 2015-01-23T19:29:33.633