What do you call this thing? "bag"?

18

1

I always need this when I buy stuff from the market. So, I need to know the real name for it. I always call it "bag" but it seems that it is not the correct name.

enter image description here

Marco Dinatsoli

Posted 2014-12-31T11:05:46.103

Reputation: 2 634

Think about polybag – Aditya ultra – 2016-12-25T07:03:23.710

I'd call it a grocery bag. I'm from the US. I'd understand if someone called it a "bag," but I wouldn't call it that myself. – user239874 – 2014-12-31T22:40:15.617

4Why don't you think it's right? – Lightness Races in Orbit – 2015-01-01T14:47:00.040

@LightnessRacesinOrbit because i used "bag" without knowing that it is the correct word, so i assumed it is the wrong word – Marco Dinatsoli – 2015-02-12T06:51:26.513

"I assume it's wrong" it's really valid prior research. Oh well! – Lightness Races in Orbit – 2015-02-12T10:15:18.510

Answers

26

In my experience, which is all I can answer from, in American English, 99% of the time the white plastic object is called a bag.

Specifically, it is a plastic bag.

We also have paper bags. And canvas bags.

When you start talking about "bags" made out of thicker material, traditionally woven from cotton or something, you can then use the word sack.

You can use sack to refer to a paper bag, but it is rare to refer to a plastic bag as a plastic sack, in the USA, using American English, at least in the dialect I speak.

So, in short, yes, bag is the most common term to call the white plastic object.

user6951

Posted 2014-12-31T11:05:46.103

Reputation:

In British English, you wouldn't call a paper bag a sack. The only plastic bags that would be referred to as "sacks" are bags for waste/rubbish/refuse/trash/garbage. – David Richerby – 2014-12-31T13:55:59.727

4In the US I've heard sack applied to paper bags as in "sack lunch" the brown paper bag your lunch would come in as a child. – Michael McGriff – 2014-12-31T14:12:38.993

When I lived in Missouri in the 1970s, a bag that the store put your stuff in was called a "sack". Apparently "bag" was some sort of insult or vulgar word. The few times I used the word "bag" people gave me a "surprised and offended" look until I caught on. I didn't care enough to pursue it at the time, I just learned to say "sack". – Jay – 2014-12-31T14:17:01.667

6"Shopping bag" would also do for any bag (paper, plastic, or canvas) that you bring home shopping in. – hobbs – 2014-12-31T16:20:39.847

@Jay - Been there, done that (see my answer). Also related: Do you call it a bag or a sack? (discussion forum).

– J.R. – 2014-12-31T17:28:50.533

@jay Times change. Today in St Louis it's a 'bag'; and in fact at the supermarket where my son works the people who put stuff in it are called 'baggers'. – StoneyB on hiatus – 2014-12-31T18:09:17.410

2@hobbs In my experience, a 'shopping bag' is a larger bag, plastic or paper, that I get from a department store such as Sears or Dillard's. Is that your usage? I would not use 'shopping bag' in the context of a market, food store, or grocery store. That is just a bag, although when full of groceries, it becomes a grocery bag. – None – 2014-12-31T18:19:48.233

1Yes @MichaelMcGriff 'sack lunch' was the term we used for a lunch packed in a small brown-paper bag (a lunch bag). But then 'sack lunch' began to refer to any lunch brought from home, even if in a lunch box. Although there are boxed lunches too. Now we have 'bag lunches' due to the ubiquity of plastic bags. But I think 'sack lunch' as a general term can still refer to any lunch from home, including a 'bag lunch'. But there are also brown bag lunches. – None – 2014-12-31T18:28:24.780

We literally call then "wal-mart bags" no matter where they're from. – corsiKa – 2014-12-31T19:09:29.840

2I understand "shopping bag" to mean a large paper bag with handles. "Lunch bag" is a much smaller bag. "Grocery bag" is in the middle. As with many phrases, the literal meaning of the words making it up is not the same as the meaning of the phrase as a whole. I would not hesitate for a moment if someone said, "I put my laundry in a grocery bag." "Grocery bag" means certain size and dimensions, not the contents. It just happens to most frequently be used at grocery stores. – Jay – 2014-12-31T19:39:08.150

1Reading all these comments just goes to show how different American English is from British English. In England, nobody calls them sacks, they are just brown bags. There is no lunch sack, sack lunch or box lunch, just lunchboxes and packed lunches (or, if provided by the school, school dinners). The term grocery bag is practically obsolete because the majority of people only ever shop at supermarket chains, and those who don't still use the term shopping bag. Much like @hobbs said, all bags used for shopping are shopping bags, irrespective of material. Interesting world. – Pharap – 2015-01-01T03:05:21.450

15

I have a funny experience with this. I grew up in the Eastern U.S. What you ask about were called bags, pure and simple.

Then I moved about 1500 miles (2400 km) away, to the American midwest, near the geographic center of U.S. I still remember my puzzled look when the cashier asked me, "Would you like a sack with that?"

Where I had grown up, a sack was made of burlap or mesh; i.e., this was a sack:

enter image description here
Fig. 1: A sack in the Northeast

But in my new location, your groceries were put in a sack, unless you wanted to carry them back to your car in your arms.

enter image description here
Fig. 2: A sack in the Midwest

By the time I moved back to the east coast more than a decade later, my ear had become accustomed to sack, and bag seemed eerily unfamiliar. I was just about certain that bag was the right word to use again, but it didn't sound right to me. So, maybe a month or so after I had moved back, I had this rather amusing conversation with a convenience store clerk while purchasing a gallon of milk:

J.R.: If I wanted one of those brown paper things to put my milk in, what would I ask for?
Cashier: A bag?
J.R.: Thank you.
Cashier: [looking confused]: Do you want one?
J.R.: No – I just wanted to know what it was called.

and then I walked out.

I think the bottom line is that regional variations may apply. I'd say bag is usually right, but you can always ask a cashier if you're not sure :^)

By the way, one question often asked in groceries stores is, "Paper or plastic?" I'd never really thought about it before, but that terse three-word question avoids the noun – which might be by design.

Lastly, remember this: If you are ever asked "Paper or plastic?" You'll have to decide for yourself. Why? Because baggers can't be choosers. ;^)

J.R.

Posted 2014-12-31T11:05:46.103

Reputation: 108 123

2+1 Good thing midnight's still 12 hours away, cause I'd hate to kick off the new year with that :). – StoneyB on hiatus – 2014-12-31T18:07:24.713

I'm from Iowa, and I recall the 'baggers' actually being called 'sackers' on occasion, with their activity being referred to as 'sacking'. That being said, 'bag', 'bagger', and 'bagging' are all probably more common. – DCShannon – 2014-12-31T23:19:52.710

1The use of sack in northeast America appears to be in line with what we in Britain would call a sack. I'm now imagining how the phrase "Santa keeps his presents in a sack" must sound to those Midwesterners. – Pharap – 2015-01-01T03:08:56.697

@Pharap - Actually, midwesterners would have no problem with that. To them, sack isn't restricted to grocery bags, but it does include them. The first and second definitions at CDO cover this quite well.

– J.R. – 2015-01-01T03:12:45.907

@J.R. I don't doubt that they would understand it, it's just that as someone who usually only ever hears sack if "spuds" or "father christmas" are in the same sentence, the idea of calling a shopping bag (or carrier bag, or plastic bag if you prefer) a sack instantly put that image in my head. – Pharap – 2015-01-01T03:21:29.433

I'd call that burlap thing a sack if I was using it for a sack race, but I might call it a bag or a sack if I using for its original purpose. Flour and other such things get put into cloth sacks, not bags. But my mom would tell me to pick up a 5 lb. (paper) bag of flour at the store. I'M SO CONFUSED NOW!!! – miltonaut – 2015-01-01T05:02:25.253

1I grew up in Omaha NE, and we "bagged" things into paper and plastic "bags" at the grocery store. Don't get caught up in idiosyncrasies. – Michael Cole – 2015-01-01T20:56:43.730

3Where in the midwest did you hear that? I'm from WI and I've never heard a disposable plastic bag called a sack like that. – Kevin – 2015-01-02T03:40:32.067

@Kevin: It wasn't WI, and it wasn't MO, but, apparently, I'm not the only one who had lived where sack was the preferred word. More here, too.

– J.R. – 2015-01-02T17:38:44.067

9

This appears to be UK-English only

It's a bag; specifically it's a carrier-bag.

You could ask for either - or even, colloquially, just 'a carrier'.

Some places would ask whether you want paper or plastic, though that's not a popular choice in the UK.
Here they prefer you to have a thicker, heavier plastic or cloth bag which can be used over & over, often referred to as a 'bag for life'

Examples -

enter image description here enter image description here

In Br Eng, this would never be a sack - that would imply it being much larger, perhaps like this, a 'bin-bag' or sack.

enter image description here

gone fishin' again.

Posted 2014-12-31T11:05:46.103

Reputation: 10 773

6I've never heard "carrier". I'm from the U.S., perhaps that's non-U.S. English. – Jay – 2014-12-31T14:13:53.943

3It's the predominant UK term; so ubiquitous it doesn't need the 'bag' part actually appending, 'carrier' alone will do to convey the meaning [when right at the point of purchase, of course] – gone fishin' again. – 2014-12-31T14:56:49.243

2

@Tetsujin Regarding the picture that the OP posted: One often sees those thin plastic ("carrier") bags caught in the branches of trees, or tangled in the hedgerow. I read once that in England they are called "witches britches" once they are out polluting the landscape. Is that actually a common term on your side of the pond? If so, well done - it has a great ring to it. (Sample usage: http://www.hastac.org/blogs/cathy-davidson/plastic-bags-trees-primer-brain-science-attention )

– Adam – 2014-12-31T17:22:18.677

2Personally I would never call a bin bag a sack, it just seems wrong somehow. @Adam Never heard them called that, but it's possible some people do, it might be a colloquialism from up North or around London or something. – Pharap – 2015-01-01T03:11:52.970

@Tetsujin I'm from the UK and I've heard them called both "plastic bags" and "carrier bags" but never just "carrier" by itself. – starsplusplus – 2015-01-02T01:35:41.543

@starsplusplus I've heard "carrier" on its own all over England. (I can't speak for the rest of the UK, having spent much less time there.) – David Richerby – 2015-01-02T13:41:58.900

I've never heard 'witches britches' to describe a rogue carrier bag. UK dialect is variable enough that I wouldn't say nobody says that, but it's certainly not in use everywhere. – ssav – 2015-01-07T11:05:41.443

8

In India, we refer that as a 'polythene bag'. Some years back, it was just a 'bag' but then due to the awareness about preserving our planet, the governments started acting strictly. All the newspapers and TV channels were flooded with the message that we should not use 'polythene bag' (there is when general public came to know the 'full form' of that bag!) However, polythene bags above 40 microns are allowed.

There are so many types of polythene but broadly, we refer these bags as polythene bags. The vendors here started using 'paper bags' and there is where, we, as buyers, have to specify the 'bag'. Suppose if I'm carrying something wet, I'll have to ask for a polythene bag over a thin paper bag that the vendor is using for everything else.


I would not prefer to put an adjective to this (such as shopping bag, grocery bag) which would simply restrict its usage! Use a polythene bag to carry a wet shoe, a fruit, a bunch of newspapers or anything that you don't 'shop' as well!

[I'm tagging this answer as InE].

Maulik V

Posted 2014-12-31T11:05:46.103

Reputation: 66 188

3Interesting. Several people here in the U.S. might call that a plastic bag, but I'd doubt you'd hear anyone say polythene. – J.R. – 2015-01-01T10:27:41.397

4Yeah, it's strange! @J.R. And you know what, a small vendor in a small village (where people don't know even the alphabet of English) use 'polythene bag'. However, their pronunciation is horrible. They don't know the word but still speak that way! In India, there are many English words used by those who don't know even a bit of the language. In fact, they even don't know that the word they speak is English. They consider such word as the latest word in their mother-tongues! :) lol – Maulik V – 2015-01-01T10:57:32.207

4

Huh. The word polythene is not (afaik) used in the US. We say polyethylene or more rarely polyethene. Polyethene or poly(methylene) is IUPAC name for the stuff. Until five minutes ago, I thought "polythene" was a nonce word John Lennon made up for the song.

– Malvolio – 2015-01-01T20:16:18.923

The term "poly bag" is used occasionally in the UK but I doubt that anyone would say "polythene bag" here unless they needed to be unusually specific about the material, e.g., for recycling. – David Richerby – 2015-01-02T13:46:49.007

@DavidRicherby Maybe, but here in India, it's polythene and I specified the reason as well. Some years back, nobody knew the full form but local govt bodies published posters for the awareness of the 'material' above 40 microns. Those posters were in regional languages. That's the reason, evrybody started calling it by that name. – Maulik V – 2015-01-03T05:07:46.940

@MaulikV I wasn't disagreeing with you -- just providing extra information. – David Richerby – 2015-01-03T09:16:00.593

1

In India wee call it a 'plastic-cover'. Well educated people also call it a 'carry-bag'.These are available in almost all types of stores in my country. In-fact because of its heavy usage and pollution problem a law was created in my state that demands these bags be made of plastic of 30 microns or above. And because in our country every state has its own language this is mostly known by it local name, in my state Kerala it is known in Malayalam as 'sanjhi'

Nidhin

Posted 2014-12-31T11:05:46.103

Reputation: 19

1

I am a product specialist in the flexible packaging industry.

The bag you have in this picture is commonly called a "t-shirt bag". It is called this because the construction moderately resembles a t-shirt. This type of bag falls under the larger category of "carry-out bag" which is any bag that a cashier will put your item in at the time of purchase and you will then carry-out of the store. The application is important when it comes to figuring out if the item is subject to import tariffs..

They are made out of LDPE or HDPE. The bag in this picture also has registered spot printing done with a flexographic press.

dave

Posted 2014-12-31T11:05:46.103

Reputation: 19

-1

In the United States, it varies by region.

enter image description here

Ben Kovitz

Posted 2014-12-31T11:05:46.103

Reputation: 25 752

In the picture you have added there is just one region :) – Marco Dinatsoli – 2015-01-08T09:17:47.630