correct usage of "you and I/me"

3

I read from a book that "you and I" replaces "we" in a sentence, while "you and me" replaces "us".

Examples:

  1. The professor wants to see you and me [us].

  2. You and I [we] will go together.

Is this correct?

I was under the notion that "I" and "me" could be used interchangeably.

user88884

Posted 2014-08-21T08:04:11.073

Reputation: 31

2Even when both I and me can be used, I wouldn't call them interchangeable—there's often a difference of register. – snailplane – 2014-08-21T11:00:11.147

Answers

2

This has to do with subject and objects in a sentence.

I see you

I is the subject and you is the object.

You see me

You is the subject and me is the object.

Subject pronouns - the one performing the action:

  • I
  • She
  • He
  • We

Object pronouns - the one receiving the action:

  • Me
  • Her
  • Him
  • Us

shinjw

Posted 2014-08-21T08:04:11.073

Reputation: 141

0

Those sentences are correct.

I is used when the speaker is the agent of the verb.

I see the dog.

I am happy.

me is used when the speaker is the patient of the verb.

The dog sees me.

She gave me the book.

Edit:

As snailplane said in the comments, you would still use I when you make a passive sentence (you don't know or say who or what is doing the action).

I am being watched. (The dog is watching me.)

I was given the book. (She gave me the book.)

Tory

Posted 2014-08-21T08:04:11.073

Reputation: 392

The forms are actually more closely aligned with syntactic roles than semantic. Consider passives: "I was given the book", not *"Me was given the book." – snailplane – 2014-08-22T08:14:04.210

@snailplane True. – Tory – 2014-08-22T13:20:49.373

I rolled back the edit. I don't think we should edit additional errors into other people's answers. – snailplane – 2014-09-22T19:40:26.960

@snailboat Though I did misspell "sentence". It doesn't help that in my dialect, it is pronounced /sɪntæns/. – Tory – 2014-09-22T21:19:54.253

1The spelling isn't important to me and I wasn't trying to point it out. I was referring to what I wrote in my first comment: I and me correspond to syntactic roles rather than semantic. – snailplane – 2014-09-23T00:22:57.037