When we join two past events, must we use the perfect participle or can we use the present participle as well?


When two incidents happen in past one after another we use past perfect tense.

By the time she got to the theatre, the play had already begun.

Is this rule also apply when we make a sentence using participle? I mean when we join two sentence happened in past one after another do we use only perfect participle or can we use present participle as well?

If we have these sentences:

We started early. We arrived at noon.

Joining using present participle:

Starting early, we arrived at noon.

Or joining using perfect participle:

Having started early,we arrived at noon.


Posted 2014-08-09T05:16:31.973

Reputation: 489

Yes, perfectly acceptable. I don't see anything wrong with your usage. – Jim – 2014-08-10T00:11:16.910



It is not a “rule” or even usual that “when two incidents happen in the past one after another we use past perfect tense”. On the contrary; in a narrative of past events we ordinarily cast all events in the simple past:

Sarah showered and changed into her nicest clothes. She dined at the little Greek restaurant down the block, and then called a cab. Traffic was heavy and she arrived at the theatre a little late.

We use the past perfect when in the course of a past narrative we wish to mention an event which occurred before the point our narrative has currently reached.

... Traffic was heavy, and when she arrived at the theatre, the play had already begun. She stood at the back of the auditorium until the first intermission, and then took her second-row seat.

Which construction you use, simple or perfect, depends on when the event you mention occurs relative to your current standpoint: your ‘reference time’ (RT), the time you are talking about. Simple constructions are used for events at RT, and perfect constructions for events which occur before RT.

A participial clause has no tense of its own—it ‘borrows’ its time reference from its head clause—but it works the same way. If the event it presents takes place at RT, we use a ‘simple’ present participle:

We retired at sundown and rose at dawn for a hurried breakfast. Starting early, we made good speed in the cool morning air and arrived at noon.

But if the event takes place before RT, we use a participial perfect:

We retired at sundown. The next day we made good speed in the cool morning air, and having left early we arrived at noon.

StoneyB on hiatus

Posted 2014-08-09T05:16:31.973

Reputation: 176 469