Plural usage of "function"

7

1

I always get confused about how to build sentences like these:

  1. What is their function?
  2. What is their functions?
  3. What are their functions?
  4. What are their function?

I think the last one sounds weird. Which one is correct, and why?

Digerkam

Posted 2013-02-23T17:22:44.483

Reputation: 611

Answers

10

With What questions, the verb must have the same number as the following noun or noun phrase, so the two correct versions are the first and the third:

What is their function? ... Here you are asking about one function and must use is.

What are their functions? ... Here you are asking about multiple functions and must use are.

Think about the answer you will get—the question must use the same verb:

Their function is this ...

Their functions are these ...

What may be confusing you is the plural their, which implies that you are asking about the function or functions of multiple things. Which of these two questions you ask will depend on the context:

What is their function? ... Here you are looking at several tools or officials or rules or whatever and assuming that they all have the same function, so you ask about a singular function.

What are their functions? ... Here you are looking at several tools or officials or rules and assuming that each has a different function, so you ask about plural functions.

Likewise, you may use these same to forms with just a single thing:

What is its function? ... Here you are looking at one thing and assuming it has only one function.

What are its functions? ... Here you are looking at one thing and assuming it has multiple functions.

StoneyB on hiatus

Posted 2013-02-23T17:22:44.483

Reputation: 176 469