parse: stop short of doing something



Wisely, he stopped short of counting his chickens, but his confidence was clear. (

There is an idiom, stop short of doing something. I suppose short of doing something could be interpreted as a predicative adjunct/complement: describing the subject semantically; modifying the verb, stop, syntactically. Is it what you have in your mind?


Posted 2014-07-11T00:36:56.057

Reputation: 25 811

3Counting one's chickens (before they hatch) is also an idiom. – None – 2014-07-11T00:38:45.957

1..and so is "conscience was clear" an idiom. **Warning~~Mixed Metaphor~~ Stopping short + counting chickens + clear conscience .** (This quote didn't come from the Age's Sports Pages by any chance, did it? LOL ;-) – doc – 2014-07-11T00:55:24.370

to stop short is a phrasal verb. – Jim – 2014-07-11T01:58:01.840



This is very tricky. What do we have in stop short of? Is it 1) as Jim suggests, a particle phrasal verb (stop short) plus an optional PP with of as its complement? 2) an ordinary stop with a PP headed by short of as a secondary subject-oriented complement? or 3) a particle-preposition phrasal verb like put up with? None of these standard tests yields entirely felicitous results:

1a. ? It was of counting his chickens that he stopped short.
2a. ? It was short of counting his chickens that he stopped.
3a. ? It was counting his chickens that he stopped short of.

1b. ? Of counting his chickens was where he stopped short.
2b. ? Short of counting his chickens was where he stopped.
3b. ? Counting his chickens was what he stopped short of.

But the idiom stop short does not ordinarily mean stop before reaching a point, but stop abruptly.

On the other hand, we do have the idiom fall short, meaning fail to reach a given goal.

And That is a point short of which I will stop is not nearly so absurd as Churchill's That is an impertinence up with which I will not put.

So on balance I’m inclined to understand short of here as a compound pronoun (with short in fall short as its intransitive variant). If I’m right, then you’re justified in understanding short of X as a locative prepositional phrase which is dependent on stop and signifies the final location of the subject.

StoneyB on hiatus

Posted 2014-07-11T00:36:56.057

Reputation: 176 469