The meaning of "I’m very cheap"?

15

Woman: I didn't know you were coming back.

Man: I wasn't, but I had made an appointment at the hair salon before I left, and they don't do refunds for cancellations. I'm very cheap.

What does "I’m very cheap" mean in this conversation?

scarlett

Posted 2018-12-12T00:37:14.667

Reputation: 1 127

Answers

27

This is a quote from the TV show, "The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel."

It is typical when complaining about someone to say, "Bob is very cheap." It's an insult and means Bob is unwilling to spend money, usually on anyone but himself. It applies in a social context, for example Bob went to a bar and didn't buy anyone but himself a drink. Or perhaps Bob never tips waiters (considered extremely rude in the US).

It would be very rare to say, "I'm very cheap." unless you were intentionally being self-deprecating as again, it's an insult.

In the show, the doctor tells Mrs. Maisel he came back to the resort because he had a haircut scheduled and is too cheap to pay for it and not get his hair cut. He's not. In fact he probably doesn't even have a haircut scheduled. It's a tongue-in-cheek/disguised way to say he really came back to see her, and she understands that. That he said it with a smile is another indicator of how it's typically used, i.e. in this context he is flirting with her and definitely not complaining or making a true statement about himself.

par

Posted 2018-12-12T00:37:14.667

Reputation: 402

35It would be very rare to say, "I'm very cheap." unless you were intentionally being self-deprecating as again, it's an insult. Not everyone is ashamed of admitting their overly frugal nature. I know people who like the challenge of driving costs down as much as humanly possible - and thus freely (and proudly) admit to doing so. – Flater – 2018-12-12T07:18:59.253

1I appreciate the additional context given, it sheds some additional light on the scenario. However, I do agree with @Flater in that there are usages of "I'm cheap" as frugal rather than miserly. – fyrepenguin – 2018-12-12T07:56:25.847

7And I agree with par that it's self-deprecating, and people proudly calling themselves frugal don't use this wording. There are many other words you can use that don't sound negative. – Mr Lister – 2018-12-12T09:30:04.113

5"Cheap" is almost always pejorative. I don't think I've ever heard anyone proudly yet non-ironically call themselves that. – Lightness Races in Orbit – 2018-12-12T11:10:35.730

1I suspected the context was as you've said, but I didn't know. – Colin Fine – 2018-12-12T12:05:26.517

9Cheap doesn't imply an unwillingness to spend money on anyone but himself, just an unwillingness to spend money, period. A cheapskate is someone who tries to avoid picking up his fair share. – jamesqf – 2018-12-12T18:35:19.913

I always say that I could be a certified cheapskate, but won't spend money on a certificate. – IMil – 2018-12-13T04:20:37.383

@jamesqf In my experience "cheapskate" is often used just to mean "frugal", "penny-pinching" with no other connotations. – IMil – 2018-12-13T04:32:55.410

5Maybe this is country-dependent but, in Australia, saying "I'm cheap" is not insulting one-self. At worst it is self-deprecating, which is something different- and simply means the person is not inclined to spend. I lady I took out a while ago described herself as a "cheap date", because she opted for a light meal and drink, over a more expensive meal with wine - in saying that, she was not giving herself an insult. – Peter – 2018-12-13T12:25:13.970

I agree with the others who have commented that cheap is no longer firmly a negative synonym for frugal. It wasn't that long ago that words like nerd and geek were only negative. Now, many people proudly use those words to describe themselves. So it is with cheap, and even the concept of using a normally negative word. Seeming self-deprecation is quite popular, but is not authentic self-deprecation. See also humblebrag. – Todd Wilcox – 2018-12-13T19:42:24.273

1@Peter As a BrE native, I would say "She is a cheap date" and "She is cheap" have very different connotations. (And hence the self-deprecation implied by saying it about oneself is different.) – Martin Bonner supports Monica – 2018-12-14T09:42:59.590

@Martin Bonner - Yes, but she made that comment, not I. Being a gentleman, I would describe her as a cheap date, rather than cheap. – Peter – 2018-12-14T10:12:50.530

31

It means "I don't like to spend more than I need to". He has paid for an appointment, so (he says) he will come for his appointment, or he would have wasted the money.

Colin Fine

Posted 2018-12-12T00:37:14.667

Reputation: 47 277

4More concise and more accurate than the accepted answer, which incorrectly identifies being cheap by its derogatory connotation alone – person27 – 2018-12-13T04:37:07.893

12

cheap (adj.): unwilling to spend money

The dialogue doesn't entirely make sense, as the relationship between the two is not clear. However what the man means is that, since he would forfeit money if he missed his appointment, he decided to get his hair cut anyway. He doesn't like to waste his money.

[Edit] As others have mentioned, "cheap" has negative connotations. The positive synonym is "frugal". It's unlikely anyone would call themselves "cheap" except perhaps to poke fun at some character trait:

I was going to buy that laptop I've been wanting for a while, but $25 for shipping is just too much. Go ahead, say it -- yeah, I'm a cheap bastard.

In this context the man does not have an appointment; rather he has invented a story to explain why he came back to see the woman. I expect it's meant to make her laugh at his self-deprecating humor.

Andrew

Posted 2018-12-12T00:37:14.667

Reputation: 85 521

7

It would be very rare to say, "I'm very cheap." unless you were intentionally being self-deprecating as again, it's an insult.

Not everyone is ashamed of admitting their overly frugal nature. I know people who like the challenge of driving costs down as much as humanly possible - and thus freely (and proudly) admit to doing so. – Flater

I agree with Flater: I have known all sorts of people - poor, middle-class, and rich people too -- who are extremely proud of how "cheap" they are! It is not considered an insult to them when you speak of them in such a way. However, you would not want to assume that someone wants to be called "cheap" when a less offensive word would be "frugal."

"Frugal," at some point in the long distant past was considered by the Romans to be a Very Good thing (see "frugal" entry at etymology.com for interesting notes about the word's long-ago origins in the Latin language).

However, as recent as 40 years ago it was not considered such a good thing by most of the people I knew during my childhood. My family's guess as to why, was that in the aftermath of the Great Depression in the U.S. (which my grandparents lived through as "poor people"), no one wanted to be poor, and poor people were forced to continue living frugally for many years, so no one wanted to be frugal because it was a sign that they were not very successful in recovering from the financial crisis.

So during that time, poor people in our area (not sure if this was true all over the country) often referred to their most frugal friends or relatives as "smart"... not that they were very intelligent, nor were they well-schooled, nor were they good readers, nor were they very well dressed... these were farmers who kept their kids out of school to work on the farm quite often. To them, "smart" meant the same thing as we would mean today if we said that a person is "frugal" and "hardworking"... but again, see that link about the Latin roots of this word "frugal," it originally had a lot to do with how hard someone worked, as well as their good choices in spending their money.

This apparent distaste for the word "frugal" was reflected in "The Frugal Gourmet," a tv show that aired starting in 1983. The show's host used to defend the word "frugal" and "remind his audience that frugal doesn't mean cheap," according to imdb.com. The host would have probably said that being frugal means not wasting money so that you have more money to spend on extremely good food.

It is amazing to me how events that shaped our history, sometimes had a powerful effect on language and what was appropriate or inappropriate to call someone. And oh, what power is held in the hands of tv hosts, even to change our perception of our language and its words! I hope this is helpful.

Oh, and par mentioned the original quote about being "cheap" came from a tv show called The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel. I looked that show up on imdb.com because I have never seen it, but the quote makes sense in more than one way, given the show's subject matter.

It is about a Jewish lady in the 1950s who wants to become successful. Jewish people are not always cheap or frugal, but in the 1950s a lot of people assumed that was true. So for a tv show set in the 1950s, it makes sense that this guy who makes the comment to the beautiful lady, is interested in her.

He was not necessarily serious that he is "cheap," but he thinks, because of his perception of her being a stereotypical Jewish person, that she would appreciate how "cheap" he behaved in coming back for his appointment. I doubt the guy actually had a hair appointment! This may have all been a part of a pickup scheme where he is interested in her romantically.

I can't find a good source that goes into depth about the history of antisemitism, but if you search on "American Jewry in the 1950's," what is returned is a nice article written about the challenges faced by the Jewish people in America prior to 1950. So 1950, the time period in which the Mrs. Maisel tv show is set, was a turning point maybe, in the history of Jewish Americans. Not sure that is a good explanation for why the doctor referred to himself as cheap, but I hope it does shed some light.

Rabbi Salomon, in his video "Cheap Jews!" on aish.com, gives a cute short talk about how he is proud to be a "cheap Jew" if that means being frugal. He gives the example of a rubber band he found on the ground, picked up, and brought home to use, as he often does with rubber bands he finds laying around. My family have Jewish roots, and we have always been quite proud of our thriftiness too! So some guy who made a romantic pass at me by pointing out how cheap he is, would make me laugh, especially if he was NOT Jewish and it was obvious to me that he was desperate to get my affections.

I looked at a lot of articles which claimed to explain the difference between "frugal" and "cheap," and this was my favorite one. It even mentions a tv show on TLC called "Extreme Cheapskates" which I hope to see an episode. https://freefrombroke.com/frugal-vs-cheap/

Thanks for the interesting topic and all the responses, I am brand new here and I probably won't make a post again. You might still be reading this one 20 years from now, ha! Sorry for the long post.

Little Carol

Posted 2018-12-12T00:37:14.667

Reputation: 127

3So to sum up, Cheap and Frugal have comparable meanings (depending on timeframe), but Frugal has connotations of pragmatism, saving money where it's not needed so that it can be better spent elsewhere, while Cheap has connotations of being outright resistant to spending money at all even when it would be more pragmatic to do so. Something of a "two sides of the same coin" situation I think. – Ruadhan2300 – 2018-12-12T10:58:30.713

2

The classic example of frugal rich people is (Walmart founder)Sam Walton's pickup truck: https://walmartmuseum.auth.cap-hosting.com/tour/exhibits/sams-truck/ "Why do I drive a pickup truck? What am I supposed to haul my dogs around in, a Rolls Royce?"

– jamesqf – 2018-12-12T18:37:52.720

@jamesqf : that almost sounds more practical to me. I would've gone with Warren Buffet's house : https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2014/10/04/what-warren-buffetts-house-can-teach-you-about-suc.aspx

– Joe – 2018-12-13T00:10:11.217

@Ruadhan2300 "Cheap has connotations of being outright resistant to spending money at all even when it would be more pragmatic to do so" - not quite, cheap means instead being resistant to spending and getting nothing back. He was going to spend the money anyway, he was not resistant to doing so. – bigbadmouse – 2018-12-13T10:13:01.363

A frugal friend and a cheap friend were each asked to bring a "special" thing to grill at a birthday party. Here is how I contrast them: My frugal friend would shop around to find the best price on various "special" meats and carefully choose something that would be affordable yet please the crowd; she would also buy enough that everyone could eat one good piece. My cheap friend would go for the cheapest thing, likely a few 99 cents packs of hotdogs, and she might buy only enough for guests to eat half a hotdog. Someone neither frugal nor cheap might buy a nice, thick steak for everyone! – Little Carol – 2018-12-16T05:10:10.047