"worthy of mention(ing)" or "worthy of a mention(ing)"?

4

That kind of happening would have definitely been worthy of mention.

or

That kind of happening would have definitely been worthy of a mention.

or

That kind of happening would have definitely been worthy of mentioning.

or

That kind of happening would have definitely been worthy of a mentioning.

?

brilliant

Posted 2018-11-29T07:24:33.627

Reputation: 2 909

All wrong, "mentionworthy". :) – stuart stevenson – 2018-11-29T15:49:41.213

Answers

3

My suggestion:

... would be definitely worth mentioning.

Alex_ander

Posted 2018-11-29T07:24:33.627

Reputation: 2 337

+1 for the conversational neutral-register option. – Tᴚoɯɐuo – 2018-11-29T10:56:02.400

2I feel like "worth mentioning" and "worthy of mention" have rather distinct and different connotations. "Worth mentioning" has a connotation of something you you should mention to whom its relevant as a courtesy. Whereas "worthy of mention" has an air of something that is somehow impressive or a great accomplishment. I guess the main distinction as I see it is that something is "worth mentioning" because the listener deserves to hear about it, whereas something is "worthy of mention" because the thing itself deserves to be known. – Shufflepants – 2018-11-29T16:04:45.290

As such, I don't think the two can be used interchangeably unless the thing being mentioned is something that fits both categories of something the listener deserves to hear and something that deserves to be heard. – Shufflepants – 2018-11-29T16:07:17.100

3

worth mentioning as Alex_ander offers is in neutral conversational register.

worthy of mention is in a slightly elevated register.

Forget the other two options, as they're not idiomatic.

worth a mention is in a more casual register.

Tᴚoɯɐuo

Posted 2018-11-29T07:24:33.627

Reputation: 116 610

worth mentioning & worth a mention are both common (UK). Don't think I've heard "worthy of mention" - it doesn't sound 'wrong', but maybe a little pompous in comparison. – Algy Taylor – 2018-11-29T15:04:09.583

I've heard "worthy of mention" used in meetings, though almost entirely in the negative, eg. "I didn't consider it worthy of mention". I've also heard it used to refer to people in this way. – DoctorPenguin – 2018-11-29T16:37:39.717

@Algy Taylor: As I wrote, "a slightly elevated register", though I wouldn't go as far as to call it "pompous" by any means. But such judgments are subjective, I will admit. – Tᴚoɯɐuo – 2018-11-29T16:40:44.370

@Tᴚoɯɐuo I've just spent 20 minutes having fun playing with this, I can't believe I didn't know about this before! – DoctorPenguin – 2018-11-29T17:00:28.157

2

According the the Oxford Dictionary, mention can be a mass noun, which does not require an a, or a countable noun which does require an a. The Oxford Dictionary states that the countable form is British only, but the American dictionary Merriam-Webster also describes a countable form.

mentioning could be an active participle or a gerund derived from the verb mention: in this context, it is an active participle, which must not be used with an a.

The first three of your examples are therefore correct: the fourth is not correct because an active participle does not take an a.


Note that definitely is a mid-position adverb, and mid-position adverbs go after the first auxiliary verb- in this case, after would.

happening can in principle be used as a singular noun, but it has a 1960's hippie feel. Event would probably be more appropriate, unless you are talking about an event where people smoked lots of hash. If you apply those two corrections, you get:

That kind of event would definitely have been worthy of mention.

JavaLatte

Posted 2018-11-29T07:24:33.627

Reputation: 43 538