the icing on the cake: Is 'on the cake' an adjunct or complement?

2

It's the icing on the cake.

Here, is on the cake an adjunct or a complement of the noun icing?

listeneva

Posted 2018-04-04T06:48:42.147

Reputation: 473

Answers

0

A complement is something that is required to complete a grammatical structure.

An adjunct is something that adds something, but is not essential for the grammar.

In a sentence "It is a red cat", a red cat is a complement, because "It is" is not complete without it. But red is an adjunct, because "It is a cat" is complete.

So you can answer your own question if you can say whether "It's the icing" is grammatically complete or not.

James K

Posted 2018-04-04T06:48:42.147

Reputation: 80 781

1I think "it's the icing" is grammatically complete. So, "on the cake" is an adjunct? – listeneva – 2018-04-04T15:51:05.947

That's good reasoning. You could write your own answer now. – James K – 2018-04-04T15:56:43.220

But there's this thinking in the back of my head hanging around saying that "it's the icing" might not mean the idiomatic "it's the icing on the cake", and therefore that "on the cake" might be a complement. What I'm asking is, just because "it's the icing" is grammatically complete, does it necessarily mean that "on the cake" is an adjunct? In It's a report on the accident., for example, It's a report. is grammatically complete, but I think on the accident is not an adjunct but a complement. – listeneva – 2018-04-04T16:18:53.213

-1

In this case, "icing on the cake" is an idiom. It only has the meaning that it does if all of the words are included. As such, it functions as a single noun in a sentence.

You can't separate part of that noun and maintain any of its meaning. So asking if "on the cake" is an adjunct or a complement of "icing" is like asking if "ngbird" is an adjunct or a complement of "mocki". I.e. I don't think this is a meaningful question.

Lorel C.

Posted 2018-04-04T06:48:42.147

Reputation: 10 949

Well, this isn't really true. "Icing" is definitely a noun with its own, non-idiomatic meaning, unlike "mocki." – Ethan B. – 2019-06-30T02:58:09.887